# Thomas Givnish — Courses & Reviews | UW–Madison [View on UW Courses](https://uwcourses.com/instructors/THOMAS_GIVNISH) ## Dataset ### revision e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349 ### repository twangodev/uwcourses ### schema version 6 ### importer version 7 ### projection id 52a78527ff09011d88cb04c7d43867d9fbfec2930bf1dd2ec359ebd2844e0b07 ### observed at 2026-09-07T15:55:43.033547+00:00 ### built at 2026-09-10T19:50:42.743001+00:00 ### courses 8951 ### current instructors 5754 ### limited false ### terms * 1272 * 1264 * 1262 * 1254 * 1252 * 1244 * 1242 * 1234 * 1232 * 1224 * 1222 * 1212 * 1204 * 1202 * 1194 * 1192 * 1184 * 1182 * 1174 * 1172 * 1164 * 1162 * 1154 * 1152 * 1144 * 1142 * 1134 * 1132 * 1124 * 1122 * 1114 * 1112 * 1104 * 1102 * 1094 * 1092 * 1084 * 1082 * 1074 * 1072 ### term 1272 ### departments | subject | count | | --------- | ----- | | AAE | 90 | | ABT | 20 | | ACCTIS | 36 | | ACTSCI | 14 | | AFAERO | 10 | | AFRICAN | 87 | | AFROAMER | 71 | | AGROECOL | 21 | | AMERIND | 53 | | ANAT\&PHY | 7 | | ANATOMY | 2 | | ANESTHES | 8 | | ANSCI | 57 | | ANTHRO | 95 | | ART | 125 | | ARTED | 10 | | ARTHIST | 121 | | ASIALANG | 129 | | ASIAN | 109 | | ASIANAM | 28 | | ASTRON | 38 | | ATMOCN | 69 | | BIOCHEM | 51 | | BIOCORE | 10 | | BIOLOGY | 14 | | BIOMDSCI | 18 | | BME | 66 | | BMI | 41 | | BMOLCHEM | 10 | | BOTANY | 69 | | BSE | 44 | | C\&ESOC | 73 | | CBE | 48 | | CHEM | 101 | | CHICLA | 52 | | CIVENGR | 133 | | CLASSICS | 47 | | CNP | 10 | | CNSRSCI | 50 | | COMARTS | 137 | | COMPBIO | 15 | | COMPLIT | 11 | | COMPSCI | 138 | | COUNPSY | 78 | | CRB | 19 | | CS\&D | 71 | | CSCS | 40 | | CURRIC | 193 | | DANCE | 93 | | DERM | 8 | | DS | 88 | | DYSCI | 35 | | ECE | 155 | | ECON | 145 | | EDPOL | 114 | | EDPSYCH | 97 | | ELPA | 70 | | EMA | 53 | | EMERMED | 17 | | ENGL | 206 | | ENTOM | 40 | | ENVIRST | 148 | | EP | 15 | | EPD | 67 | | ESL | 16 | | F\&WECOL | 60 | | FAMMED | 22 | | FINANCE | 50 | | FOLKLORE | 40 | | FOODSCI | 43 | | FRENCH | 63 | | GEN\&WS | 145 | | GENBUS | 72 | | GENECSLR | 17 | | GENETICS | 60 | | GEOG | 113 | | GEOSCI | 83 | | GERMAN | 82 | | GLE | 48 | | GNS | 38 | | GREEK | 27 | | HDFS | 41 | | HEBR-BIB | 13 | | HEBR-MOD | 10 | | HISTORY | 233 | | HISTSCI | 56 | | HONCOL | 13 | | ILS | 43 | | INFOSYS | 9 | | INTEGART | 7 | | INTEGSCI | 22 | | INTER-AG | 18 | | INTER-HE | 11 | | INTER-LS | 22 | | INTEREGR | 16 | | INTLBUS | 21 | | INTLST | 50 | | ISYE | 83 | | ITALIAN | 53 | | JEWISH | 56 | | JOURN | 88 | | KINES | 128 | | LACIS | 26 | | LANDARC | 61 | | LATIN | 24 | | LAW | 120 | | LEGALST | 48 | | LINGUIS | 35 | | LIS | 89 | | LITTRANS | 78 | | LSC | 52 | | M\&ENVTOX | 7 | | MARKETNG | 62 | | MATH | 153 | | MDGENET | 8 | | ME | 130 | | MEDHIST | 43 | | MEDICINE | 60 | | MEDIEVAL | 32 | | MEDPHYS | 39 | | MEDSC-M | 29 | | MEDSC-V | 41 | | MHR | 68 | | MICROBIO | 45 | | MILSCI | 16 | | MM\&I | 22 | | MOLBIOL | 6 | | MS\&E | 59 | | MUSIC | 165 | | MUSPERF | 126 | | NAVSCI | 20 | | NE | 44 | | NEURODPT | 11 | | NEUROL | 7 | | NEURSURG | 4 | | NTP | 11 | | NURSING | 111 | | NUTRSCI | 65 | | OBS\&GYN | 18 | | OCCTHER | 39 | | ONCOLOGY | 14 | | OPHTHALM | 5 | | OTM | 43 | | PATH | 34 | | PATH-BIO | 29 | | PEDIAT | 26 | | PHARMACY | 31 | | PHILOS | 77 | | PHMCOL-M | 11 | | PHMPRAC | 45 | | PHMSCI | 60 | | PHYASST | 37 | | PHYSICS | 88 | | PHYSIOL | 3 | | PHYTHER | 37 | | PLANTSCI | 52 | | PLPATH | 35 | | POLISCI | 192 | | POPHLTH | 58 | | PORTUG | 33 | | PSYCH | 101 | | PSYCHIAT | 22 | | PUBAFFR | 54 | | PUBLHLTH | 23 | | RADIOL | 11 | | REALEST | 41 | | RELIGST | 90 | | RHABMED | 9 | | RMI | 24 | | RP\&SE | 102 | | S\&APHM | 17 | | SCANDST | 73 | | SLAVIC | 89 | | SOC | 149 | | SOCWORK | 87 | | SOILSCI | 46 | | SPANISH | 83 | | SRMED | 21 | | STAT | 94 | | STDYABRD | 52 | | STS | 8 | | SURGERY | 25 | | SURGSCI | 33 | | THEATRE | 91 | | URBRPL | 60 | | UROLOGY | 5 | | ZOOLOGY | 89 | ## instructor ### instructor uid instructor\_06376d6631a07487874769dd ### source enrollment ### source instructor id givnish ### identity basis netid ### identity status source\_identified ### name Thomas Givnish ### email GIVNISH\@WISC.EDU ### first observed at 2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00 ### last observed at 2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00 ### ratings #### review count 28 #### quality 2.71 #### difficulty 4.11 #### quality count 28 #### difficulty count 28 #### profile id rmp:383844 #### source url #### match basis exact\_name #### observed at 2026-09-07 16:02:09.376183+00:00 #### courses ##### course d5149edf8c7ee88fdc8c9825 ###### review count 3 ###### quality 1 ###### difficulty 4.33 ###### quality count 3 ###### difficulty count 3 #### bayesian quality 3.1057024098110815 #### prior mean 3.6596857835465957 #### prior weight 20 ### current true ### courses | course\_uid | course\_id | title | credits\_min | credits\_max | gpa | | -------------------------------- | ---------- | -------------------------- | ------------ | ------------ | --- | | course\_b515cb433812f952f159f714 | BOTANY 994 | RESEARCH-PLANT SYSTEMATICS | 1 | 12 | | | course\_d70715157381874be5a4f340 | BOTANY 995 | RESEARCH-PLANT ECOLOGY | 1 | 12 | | | course\_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db | BOTANY 682 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS | 3 | 3 | 4 | | course\_fe1df643877efda42dc93503 | BOTANY 681 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS | 3 | 3 | | ### revision e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349 ### instructor url /instructors/THOMAS\_GIVNISH ## history | term | course\_uid | course\_id | title | | ---- | -------------------------------- | ---------- | -------------------------- | | 1272 | course\_fe1df643877efda42dc93503 | BOTANY 681 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS | | 1272 | course\_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db | BOTANY 682 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS | | 1272 | course\_b515cb433812f952f159f714 | BOTANY 994 | RESEARCH-PLANT SYSTEMATICS | | 1272 | course\_d70715157381874be5a4f340 | BOTANY 995 | RESEARCH-PLANT ECOLOGY | ## timeline | term | courses | | ---- | ------- | | 1272 | 4 | ## term 1272 ## courses ```json [ { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "course_id": "BOTANY 681", "title": "SENIOR HONORS THESIS", "credits_min": 3, "credits_max": 3, "gpa": null, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: Simon Gilroy (4.47/5 adjusted; 127 ratings); David Baum (4.29/5 adjusted; 87 ratings); Hiroshi Maeda (4.15/5 adjusted; 21 ratings); Ken Keefover-Ring (4.06/5 adjusted; 30 ratings); Kate McCulloh (4.04/5 adjusted; 27 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "Simon Gilroy", "href": "/instructors/SIMON_GILROY" }, { "label": "David Baum", "href": "/instructors/DAVID_BAUM" }, { "label": "Hiroshi Maeda", "href": "/instructors/HIROSHI_MAEDA" }, { "label": "Ken Keefover-Ring", "href": "/instructors/KEN_KEEFOVER-RING" }, { "label": "Kate McCulloh", "href": "/instructors/KATE_MCCULLOH" } ] } ], "description": "BOTANY 681 is a senior honors thesis course involving individual research arranged with a faculty member for Botany majors.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_874bcbea3577ff696078b3a9", "name": "Simon Gilroy", "quality": 4.472066092999537, "quality_count": 127, "instructor_url": "/instructors/SIMON_GILROY" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_e704ef62b73aaa221ac621ac", "name": "David Baum", "quality": 4.2860160343077744, "quality_count": 87, "instructor_url": "/instructors/DAVID_BAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_ea197284dc67cb5b3d133645", "name": "Hiroshi Maeda", "quality": 4.151554040754436, "quality_count": 21, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HIROSHI_MAEDA" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_9d4fadeb4d3a84f59ddf5739", "name": "Ken Keefover-Ring", "quality": 4.061874313418638, "quality_count": 30, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KEN_KEEFOVER-RING" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_963f2c323f2445faf16f1bf9", "name": "Kate McCulloh", "quality": 4.0447599078921685, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KATE_MCCULLOH" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_059eed5b9a0f247cb8cde885", "name": "Anne Pringle", "quality": 3.8064571890310637, "quality_count": 10, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNE_PRINGLE" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_e07c4a420217ae0ac05d6c15", "name": "Cecile Ane", "quality": 3.7994384714114453, "quality_count": 9, "instructor_url": "/instructors/CECILE_ANE" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_ae0064c3d18eec7680c7acd1", "name": "Richard Lankau", "quality": 3.781532530496905, "quality_count": 2, "instructor_url": "/instructors/RICHARD_LANKAU" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_4643c3c0043c80d44b2c8c33", "name": "Daijiang Li", "quality": 3.5497381529554963, "quality_count": 4, "instructor_url": "/instructors/DAIJIANG_LI" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_0464e305ece66ef5f57c55dc", "name": "Marisa Otegui", "quality": 3.546681371958919, "quality_count": 6, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARISA_OTEGUI" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_06376d6631a07487874769dd", "name": "Thomas Givnish", "quality": 3.1057024098110815, "quality_count": 28, "instructor_url": "/instructors/THOMAS_GIVNISH" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_cc64248635c2059468e91f40", "name": "Sara Hotchkiss", "quality": 3.068164163211317, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/SARA_HOTCHKISS" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_dde6e473397ca5ae4883e77a", "name": "Eve Emshwiller", "quality": 2.7880675576533074, "quality_count": 35, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EVE_EMSHWILLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_29904f9d8958e478b75f1722", "name": "Jack Satterlee", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JACK_SATTERLEE" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_3ffbb957d253af1ecec8f9c1", "name": "Kenneth Cameron", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KENNETH_CAMERON" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_c17f9679cfe9f3ced96d9b5f", "name": "Kenneth Sytsma", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KENNETH_SYTSMA" }, { "course_uid": "course_fe1df643877efda42dc93503", "uid": "instructor_1e7de74076042a0ca32424f2", "name": "Shan He", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/SHAN_HE" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "course_id": "BOTANY 682", "title": "SENIOR HONORS THESIS", "credits_min": 3, "credits_max": 3, "gpa": 4, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: Simon Gilroy (4.47/5 adjusted; 127 ratings); David Baum (4.29/5 adjusted; 87 ratings); Hiroshi Maeda (4.15/5 adjusted; 21 ratings); Ken Keefover-Ring (4.06/5 adjusted; 30 ratings); Kate McCulloh (4.04/5 adjusted; 27 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "Simon Gilroy", "href": "/instructors/SIMON_GILROY" }, { "label": "David Baum", "href": "/instructors/DAVID_BAUM" }, { "label": "Hiroshi Maeda", "href": "/instructors/HIROSHI_MAEDA" }, { "label": "Ken Keefover-Ring", "href": "/instructors/KEN_KEEFOVER-RING" }, { "label": "Kate McCulloh", "href": "/instructors/KATE_MCCULLOH" } ] } ], "description": "BOTANY 682 is a senior honors thesis course involving individual research arranged with a faculty member for Botany majors.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 2, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 2, "gpa": 4, "topShare": 100, "firstTerm": "1224", "lastTerm": "1224" }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_874bcbea3577ff696078b3a9", "name": "Simon Gilroy", "quality": 4.472066092999537, "quality_count": 127, "instructor_url": "/instructors/SIMON_GILROY" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_e704ef62b73aaa221ac621ac", "name": "David Baum", "quality": 4.2860160343077744, "quality_count": 87, "instructor_url": "/instructors/DAVID_BAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_ea197284dc67cb5b3d133645", "name": "Hiroshi Maeda", "quality": 4.151554040754436, "quality_count": 21, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HIROSHI_MAEDA" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_9d4fadeb4d3a84f59ddf5739", "name": "Ken Keefover-Ring", "quality": 4.061874313418638, "quality_count": 30, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KEN_KEEFOVER-RING" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_963f2c323f2445faf16f1bf9", "name": "Kate McCulloh", "quality": 4.0447599078921685, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KATE_MCCULLOH" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_059eed5b9a0f247cb8cde885", "name": "Anne Pringle", "quality": 3.8064571890310637, "quality_count": 10, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNE_PRINGLE" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_e07c4a420217ae0ac05d6c15", "name": "Cecile Ane", "quality": 3.7994384714114453, "quality_count": 9, "instructor_url": "/instructors/CECILE_ANE" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_4643c3c0043c80d44b2c8c33", "name": "Daijiang Li", "quality": 3.5497381529554963, "quality_count": 4, "instructor_url": "/instructors/DAIJIANG_LI" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_0464e305ece66ef5f57c55dc", "name": "Marisa Otegui", "quality": 3.546681371958919, "quality_count": 6, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARISA_OTEGUI" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_06376d6631a07487874769dd", "name": "Thomas Givnish", "quality": 3.1057024098110815, "quality_count": 28, "instructor_url": "/instructors/THOMAS_GIVNISH" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_cc64248635c2059468e91f40", "name": "Sara Hotchkiss", "quality": 3.068164163211317, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/SARA_HOTCHKISS" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_dde6e473397ca5ae4883e77a", "name": "Eve Emshwiller", "quality": 2.7880675576533074, "quality_count": 35, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EVE_EMSHWILLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_29904f9d8958e478b75f1722", "name": "Jack Satterlee", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JACK_SATTERLEE" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_3ffbb957d253af1ecec8f9c1", "name": "Kenneth Cameron", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KENNETH_CAMERON" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_c17f9679cfe9f3ced96d9b5f", "name": "Kenneth Sytsma", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KENNETH_SYTSMA" }, { "course_uid": "course_e22fe32a111fdf1a7bc392db", "uid": "instructor_1e7de74076042a0ca32424f2", "name": "Shan He", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/SHAN_HE" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_b515cb433812f952f159f714", "course_id": "BOTANY 994", "title": "RESEARCH-PLANT SYSTEMATICS", "credits_min": 1, "credits_max": 12, "gpa": null, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: David Baum (4.29/5 adjusted; 87 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "David Baum", "href": "/instructors/DAVID_BAUM" } ] } ], "description": "BOTANY 994 is an independent research course focused on plant systematics.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_b515cb433812f952f159f714", "uid": "instructor_e704ef62b73aaa221ac621ac", "name": "David Baum", "quality": 4.2860160343077744, "quality_count": 87, "instructor_url": "/instructors/DAVID_BAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_b515cb433812f952f159f714", "uid": "instructor_e07c4a420217ae0ac05d6c15", "name": "Cecile Ane", "quality": 3.7994384714114453, "quality_count": 9, "instructor_url": "/instructors/CECILE_ANE" }, { "course_uid": "course_b515cb433812f952f159f714", "uid": "instructor_06376d6631a07487874769dd", "name": "Thomas Givnish", "quality": 3.1057024098110815, "quality_count": 28, "instructor_url": "/instructors/THOMAS_GIVNISH" }, { "course_uid": "course_b515cb433812f952f159f714", "uid": "instructor_dde6e473397ca5ae4883e77a", "name": "Eve Emshwiller", "quality": 2.7880675576533074, "quality_count": 35, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EVE_EMSHWILLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_b515cb433812f952f159f714", "uid": "instructor_99f0b293a42d22df2a89c865", "name": "Daniel Spalink", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/DANIEL_SPALINK" }, { "course_uid": "course_b515cb433812f952f159f714", "uid": "instructor_3ffbb957d253af1ecec8f9c1", "name": "Kenneth Cameron", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KENNETH_CAMERON" }, { "course_uid": "course_b515cb433812f952f159f714", "uid": "instructor_c17f9679cfe9f3ced96d9b5f", "name": "Kenneth Sytsma", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KENNETH_SYTSMA" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "course_id": "BOTANY 995", "title": "RESEARCH-PLANT ECOLOGY", "credits_min": 1, "credits_max": 12, "gpa": null, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: Ken Keefover-Ring (4.06/5 adjusted; 30 ratings); Kate McCulloh (4.04/5 adjusted; 27 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "Ken Keefover-Ring", "href": "/instructors/KEN_KEEFOVER-RING" }, { "label": "Kate McCulloh", "href": "/instructors/KATE_MCCULLOH" } ] } ], "description": "BOTANY 995 is an independent research course in the area of Plant Ecology.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "uid": "instructor_9d4fadeb4d3a84f59ddf5739", "name": "Ken Keefover-Ring", "quality": 4.061874313418638, "quality_count": 30, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KEN_KEEFOVER-RING" }, { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "uid": "instructor_963f2c323f2445faf16f1bf9", "name": "Kate McCulloh", "quality": 4.0447599078921685, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/KATE_MCCULLOH" }, { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "uid": "instructor_d3adc46fc35037f749e45d02", "name": "Ellen Damschen", "quality": 3.7489766485623983, "quality_count": 35, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLEN_DAMSCHEN" }, { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "uid": "instructor_4643c3c0043c80d44b2c8c33", "name": "Daijiang Li", "quality": 3.5497381529554963, "quality_count": 4, "instructor_url": "/instructors/DAIJIANG_LI" }, { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "uid": "instructor_06376d6631a07487874769dd", "name": "Thomas Givnish", "quality": 3.1057024098110815, "quality_count": 28, "instructor_url": "/instructors/THOMAS_GIVNISH" }, { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "uid": "instructor_cc64248635c2059468e91f40", "name": "Sara Hotchkiss", "quality": 3.068164163211317, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/SARA_HOTCHKISS" }, { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "uid": "instructor_dde6e473397ca5ae4883e77a", "name": "Eve Emshwiller", "quality": 2.7880675576533074, "quality_count": 35, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EVE_EMSHWILLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_d70715157381874be5a4f340", "uid": "instructor_8101a18ce3b818d780d8e359", "name": "Chris Muir", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/CHRIS_MUIR" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } } ] ``` ## reviews ### items ```json [ { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:02:09.376183+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM5MzA3NDE0", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:383844", "instructor_name": "Thomas Givnish", "course_label": "BOT460", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2024-04-30 01:53:53 +0000 UTC", "comment": "Dr. Givnish's lectures can be fairly disorganized and research-heavy (difficult to know what concepts you will be graded on). Although he does genuinely care about his students he can come off as very intimidating at times. Botany 460 is an interesting class but be prepared for a lot of work coming from studying and a big research project in lab.", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/383844", "quality_rating": 2, "difficulty_rating": 4 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:02:09.376183+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM5MjQ1OTA4", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:383844", "instructor_name": "Thomas Givnish", "course_label": "BOTANY460", "course_id": "BOTANY/ZOOLOGY 460", "course_uid": "course_d5149edf8c7ee88fdc8c9825", "review_date": "2024-04-24 01:16:30 +0000 UTC", "comment": "I dropped this class due to the confusing and disorganized teaching style. He would rush through complicated topics with wordy definitions and spend the rest of lecture on loosely related examples.The exams were heavily based in the readings (old research papers) that had to be memorized. I didn't learn much at all from my 6 weeks of this class.", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/383844", "quality_rating": 1, "difficulty_rating": 4 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:02:09.376183+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM3NDU0OTIx", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:383844", "instructor_name": "Thomas Givnish", "course_label": "BOT460", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2023-02-24 01:42:14 +0000 UTC", "comment": "Tom's classes are definitely hard and require a lot of effort, but if you put in as much effort as he does you'll learn a ton. He admittedly seems scary and rude but honestly he does care a lot about students passing his classes and learning, he's just super smart and I think sometimes forgets that we aren't all on his level. ", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/383844", "quality_rating": 5, "difficulty_rating": 5 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:02:09.376183+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM2Mzk3NjYw", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:383844", "instructor_name": "Thomas Givnish", "course_label": "BOT460", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2022-05-24 02:41:14 +0000 UTC", "comment": "While Dr. Givnish is very knowledgeable but he isn't a great lecturer. He runs through material very quickly and focuses a lot on his research & interests (Hawaiian flora). I never felt comfortable asking a question in lecture. His tests are very challenging and he takes no accountability for his dysfunctional teaching style. Avoid if you can.", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/383844", "quality_rating": 2, "difficulty_rating": 5 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:02:09.376183+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM2MDY0ODg1", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:383844", "instructor_name": "Thomas Givnish", "course_label": "BOT460", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2022-04-12 20:12:06 +0000 UTC", "comment": "Lectures are boring and FULL of information, he is way too smart to be teaching an intro ecol. class. Also he's kind of mean when people asked questions in class\nThings I recommend:\n- don't waste your time reading the textbook\n- Do read and understand the discussion texts (they show up on exams)\n- practice exams are very similar to real exam", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/383844", "quality_rating": 2, "difficulty_rating": 4 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:02:09.376183+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM2MDQ0MTEz", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:383844", "instructor_name": "Thomas Givnish", "course_label": "BOT460", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2022-04-08 16:42:13 +0000 UTC", "comment": "Very few resources given to succeed on exams that are graded at a high difficulty. Only given a few practice questions (with no answer key) to prepare. Prof is intimidating and will NOT record lectures so don't bother asking. Grading is not consistent. DON'T TAKE unless absolutely necessary. ", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/383844", "quality_rating": 1, "difficulty_rating": 5 } ] ``` ### total 28 ### page 1 ### courses | course\_uid | course\_id | | -------------------------------- | ------------------ | | course\_d5149edf8c7ee88fdc8c9825 | BOTANY/ZOOLOGY 460 | ### matched true ## social Image true