# Paula Gottlieb — Courses & Reviews | UW–Madison [View on UW Courses](https://uwcourses.com/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB) ## Dataset ### revision e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349 ### repository twangodev/uwcourses ### schema version 6 ### importer version 7 ### projection id 52a78527ff09011d88cb04c7d43867d9fbfec2930bf1dd2ec359ebd2844e0b07 ### observed at 2026-09-07T15:55:43.033547+00:00 ### built at 2026-09-10T19:50:42.743001+00:00 ### courses 8951 ### current instructors 5754 ### limited false ### terms * 1272 * 1264 * 1262 * 1254 * 1252 * 1244 * 1242 * 1234 * 1232 * 1224 * 1222 * 1212 * 1204 * 1202 * 1194 * 1192 * 1184 * 1182 * 1174 * 1172 * 1164 * 1162 * 1154 * 1152 * 1144 * 1142 * 1134 * 1132 * 1124 * 1122 * 1114 * 1112 * 1104 * 1102 * 1094 * 1092 * 1084 * 1082 * 1074 * 1072 ### term 1272 ### departments | subject | count | | --------- | ----- | | AAE | 90 | | ABT | 20 | | ACCTIS | 36 | | ACTSCI | 14 | | AFAERO | 10 | | AFRICAN | 87 | | AFROAMER | 71 | | AGROECOL | 21 | | AMERIND | 53 | | ANAT\&PHY | 7 | | ANATOMY | 2 | | ANESTHES | 8 | | ANSCI | 57 | | ANTHRO | 95 | | ART | 125 | | ARTED | 10 | | ARTHIST | 121 | | ASIALANG | 129 | | ASIAN | 109 | | ASIANAM | 28 | | ASTRON | 38 | | ATMOCN | 69 | | BIOCHEM | 51 | | BIOCORE | 10 | | BIOLOGY | 14 | | BIOMDSCI | 18 | | BME | 66 | | BMI | 41 | | BMOLCHEM | 10 | | BOTANY | 69 | | BSE | 44 | | C\&ESOC | 73 | | CBE | 48 | | CHEM | 101 | | CHICLA | 52 | | CIVENGR | 133 | | CLASSICS | 47 | | CNP | 10 | | CNSRSCI | 50 | | COMARTS | 137 | | COMPBIO | 15 | | COMPLIT | 11 | | COMPSCI | 138 | | COUNPSY | 78 | | CRB | 19 | | CS\&D | 71 | | CSCS | 40 | | CURRIC | 193 | | DANCE | 93 | | DERM | 8 | | DS | 88 | | DYSCI | 35 | | ECE | 155 | | ECON | 145 | | EDPOL | 114 | | EDPSYCH | 97 | | ELPA | 70 | | EMA | 53 | | EMERMED | 17 | | ENGL | 206 | | ENTOM | 40 | | ENVIRST | 148 | | EP | 15 | | EPD | 67 | | ESL | 16 | | F\&WECOL | 60 | | FAMMED | 22 | | FINANCE | 50 | | FOLKLORE | 40 | | FOODSCI | 43 | | FRENCH | 63 | | GEN\&WS | 145 | | GENBUS | 72 | | GENECSLR | 17 | | GENETICS | 60 | | GEOG | 113 | | GEOSCI | 83 | | GERMAN | 82 | | GLE | 48 | | GNS | 38 | | GREEK | 27 | | HDFS | 41 | | HEBR-BIB | 13 | | HEBR-MOD | 10 | | HISTORY | 233 | | HISTSCI | 56 | | HONCOL | 13 | | ILS | 43 | | INFOSYS | 9 | | INTEGART | 7 | | INTEGSCI | 22 | | INTER-AG | 18 | | INTER-HE | 11 | | INTER-LS | 22 | | INTEREGR | 16 | | INTLBUS | 21 | | INTLST | 50 | | ISYE | 83 | | ITALIAN | 53 | | JEWISH | 56 | | JOURN | 88 | | KINES | 128 | | LACIS | 26 | | LANDARC | 61 | | LATIN | 24 | | LAW | 120 | | LEGALST | 48 | | LINGUIS | 35 | | LIS | 89 | | LITTRANS | 78 | | LSC | 52 | | M\&ENVTOX | 7 | | MARKETNG | 62 | | MATH | 153 | | MDGENET | 8 | | ME | 130 | | MEDHIST | 43 | | MEDICINE | 60 | | MEDIEVAL | 32 | | MEDPHYS | 39 | | MEDSC-M | 29 | | MEDSC-V | 41 | | MHR | 68 | | MICROBIO | 45 | | MILSCI | 16 | | MM\&I | 22 | | MOLBIOL | 6 | | MS\&E | 59 | | MUSIC | 165 | | MUSPERF | 126 | | NAVSCI | 20 | | NE | 44 | | NEURODPT | 11 | | NEUROL | 7 | | NEURSURG | 4 | | NTP | 11 | | NURSING | 111 | | NUTRSCI | 65 | | OBS\&GYN | 18 | | OCCTHER | 39 | | ONCOLOGY | 14 | | OPHTHALM | 5 | | OTM | 43 | | PATH | 34 | | PATH-BIO | 29 | | PEDIAT | 26 | | PHARMACY | 31 | | PHILOS | 77 | | PHMCOL-M | 11 | | PHMPRAC | 45 | | PHMSCI | 60 | | PHYASST | 37 | | PHYSICS | 88 | | PHYSIOL | 3 | | PHYTHER | 37 | | PLANTSCI | 52 | | PLPATH | 35 | | POLISCI | 192 | | POPHLTH | 58 | | PORTUG | 33 | | PSYCH | 101 | | PSYCHIAT | 22 | | PUBAFFR | 54 | | PUBLHLTH | 23 | | RADIOL | 11 | | REALEST | 41 | | RELIGST | 90 | | RHABMED | 9 | | RMI | 24 | | RP\&SE | 102 | | S\&APHM | 17 | | SCANDST | 73 | | SLAVIC | 89 | | SOC | 149 | | SOCWORK | 87 | | SOILSCI | 46 | | SPANISH | 83 | | SRMED | 21 | | STAT | 94 | | STDYABRD | 52 | | STS | 8 | | SURGERY | 25 | | SURGSCI | 33 | | THEATRE | 91 | | URBRPL | 60 | | UROLOGY | 5 | | ZOOLOGY | 89 | ## instructor ### instructor uid instructor\_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428 ### source enrollment ### source instructor id plgottli ### identity basis netid ### identity status source\_identified ### name Paula Gottlieb ### email PLGOTTLI\@WISC.EDU ### first observed at 2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00 ### last observed at 2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00 ### ratings #### review count 27 #### quality 3.7 #### difficulty 2.56 #### quality count 27 #### difficulty count 27 #### profile id rmp:589692 #### source url #### match basis exact\_name #### observed at 2026-09-07 16:12:17.664313+00:00 #### courses ##### course 7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116 ###### review count 4 ###### quality 3 ###### difficulty 2.75 ###### quality count 4 ###### difficulty count 4 #### bayesian quality 3.682845014275147 #### prior mean 3.6596857835465957 #### prior weight 20 ### current true ### courses | course\_uid | course\_id | title | credits\_min | credits\_max | gpa | | -------------------------------- | ---------- | ----------------------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ----- | | course\_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3 | PHILOS 990 | RESEARCH AND THESIS | 2 | 9 | | | course\_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076 | PHILOS 699 | DIRECTED STUDY | 2 | 3 | | | course\_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556 | PHILOS 999 | INDEPENDENT WORK | 2 | 9 | 4 | | course\_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280 | PHILOS 682 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS | 3 | 3 | 4 | | course\_3b120ec1ba8cd3bb6069f791 | PHILOS 454 | CLASSICAL PHILOSOPHERS | 3 | 3 | 3.596 | | course\_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810 | PHILOS 681 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS | 1 | 3 | | | course\_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116 | PHILOS 430 | HISTORY OF ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY | 3 | 4 | 3.504 | | course\_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474 | PHILOS 599 | DIRECTED STUDY | 1 | 3 | 4 | ### revision e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349 ### instructor url /instructors/PAULA\_GOTTLIEB ## history | term | course\_uid | course\_id | title | | ---- | -------------------------------- | ---------- | ----------------------------- | | 1272 | course\_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116 | PHILOS 430 | HISTORY OF ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY | | 1272 | course\_3b120ec1ba8cd3bb6069f791 | PHILOS 454 | CLASSICAL PHILOSOPHERS | | 1272 | course\_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474 | PHILOS 599 | DIRECTED STUDY | | 1272 | course\_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810 | PHILOS 681 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS | | 1272 | course\_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280 | PHILOS 682 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS | | 1272 | course\_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076 | PHILOS 699 | DIRECTED STUDY | | 1272 | course\_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3 | PHILOS 990 | RESEARCH AND THESIS | | 1272 | course\_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556 | PHILOS 999 | INDEPENDENT WORK | ## timeline | term | courses | | ---- | ------- | | 1272 | 8 | ## term 1272 ## courses ```json [ { "course_uid": "course_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116", "course_id": "PHILOS 430", "title": "HISTORY OF ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY", "credits_min": 3, "credits_max": 4, "gpa": 3.504, "badges": [], "description": "HISTORY OF ANCIENT PHILOSOPHY covers philosophers from the presocratics to the Stoics and Epicureans, with particular emphasis on Plato and Aristotle.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 272, 131, 35, 5, 7, 0, 1 ], "count": 451, "gpa": 3.720620842572062, "topShare": 89.3569844789357, "firstTerm": "1232", "lastTerm": "1264" }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116", "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428", "name": "Paula Gottlieb", "quality": 3.682845014275147, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB" }, { "course_uid": "course_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116", "uid": "instructor_760cdd9127ca179912ac4779", "name": "S. Riza Qadri", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/S_RIZA_QADRI" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": { "citations": [ { "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "review_date": "2005-12-16 12:52:06 +0000 UTC", "review_id": "73221ae5707c5222c0f8cf2d", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTExMTg0OTc1", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "type": "review" }, { "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "review_date": "2019-11-05 04:06:20 +0000 UTC", "review_id": "b37591e4f40ddeb6172473fd", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTMyMzU4NTcw", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "type": "review" }, { "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "review_date": "2023-12-13 03:41:39 +0000 UTC", "review_id": "73e5b1cb6afe6fee4c12424e", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM4NjQyOTA3", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "type": "review" } ], "text": "Paula Gottlieb’s lectures are frequently described as boring or monotonous, with one student noting her voice puts them to sleep. Reviewers also criticize the lack of syllabus dates and a 'swing' grading strategy that some find unfair or confusing." }, "reviewFiles": [ "/data/e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349/reviews/course_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116-0.json" ] } }, { "course_uid": "course_3b120ec1ba8cd3bb6069f791", "course_id": "PHILOS 454", "title": "CLASSICAL PHILOSOPHERS", "credits_min": 3, "credits_max": 3, "gpa": 3.596, "badges": [ { "id": "grade-outcomes", "label": "Higher grades", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Spring 2026 · latest released grades before Fall 2026: 3.83 GPA across 51 letter grades, versus 3.62 for UW–Madison (1283 courses). Requires a difference of at least 0.20 and 30 letter grades. Historical outcomes, not predicted difficulty.", "sources": [ { "label": "Grade history and sources", "href": "/courses/PHILOS_454#grades" } ] }, { "id": "lecture-size", "label": "Small lectures", "tone": "neutral", "evidence": "Fall 2026: median 22 enrolled students across 2 recorded lecture sections. Small means 30 or fewer; large means 100 or more. Enrollment at scan time, not capacity or typical historical attendance.", "sources": [ { "label": "Sections and enrollment", "href": "/courses/PHILOS_454#schedule" } ] } ], "description": "PHILOS 454 offers intensive study of selected classical philosophers, movements, or problems.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 148, 46, 13, 1, 3, 0, 0 ], "count": 211, "gpa": 3.793838862559242, "topShare": 91.9431279620853, "firstTerm": "1224", "lastTerm": "1264" }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_3b120ec1ba8cd3bb6069f791", "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428", "name": "Paula Gottlieb", "quality": 3.682845014275147, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB" }, { "course_uid": "course_3b120ec1ba8cd3bb6069f791", "uid": "instructor_e7997e31ce9c9d5d1d070f7a", "name": "Jeremy Manheim", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JEREMY_MANHEIM" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": { "citations": [ { "course_id": "PHILOS 454", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "section_number": 1, "source_course_id": "e674de48-f336-3bf2-814e-44a2ec954dd7", "source_record": { "entity_id": "e674de48-f336-3bf2-814e-44a2ec954dd7", "file": "tables/observations.parquet", "kind": "grades", "source": "madgrades" }, "table": "section_grades_latest", "term_id": "1232", "type": "grade" }, { "course_id": "PHILOS 454", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "section_number": 1, "source_course_id": "e674de48-f336-3bf2-814e-44a2ec954dd7", "source_record": { "entity_id": "e674de48-f336-3bf2-814e-44a2ec954dd7", "file": "tables/observations.parquet", "kind": "grades", "source": "madgrades" }, "table": "section_grades_latest", "term_id": "1252", "type": "grade" }, { "course_id": "PHILOS 454", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "section_number": 1, "source_course_id": "e674de48-f336-3bf2-814e-44a2ec954dd7", "source_record": { "entity_id": "e674de48-f336-3bf2-814e-44a2ec954dd7", "file": "tables/observations.parquet", "kind": "grades", "source": "madgrades" }, "table": "section_grades_latest", "term_id": "1262", "type": "grade" } ], "text": "Recent recorded grades — Fall 2022: 3.75 GPA, 91.7% A/AB (n=12 letter grades); Fall 2024: 3.76 GPA, 82.6% A/AB (n=23 letter grades); Fall 2025: 3.88 GPA, 100.0% A/AB (n=16 letter grades)." }, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "course_id": "PHILOS 599", "title": "DIRECTED STUDY", "credits_min": 1, "credits_max": 3, "gpa": 4, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "James Messina", "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "label": "Larry Shapiro", "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "label": "Steven Nadler", "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "label": "Harry Brighouse", "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "label": "Michael Titelbaum", "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "label": "Peter Vranas", "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" } ] } ], "description": "PHILOS 599 is a directed study course allowing students to pursue independent research or study topics arranged with a faculty member.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 9, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 9, "gpa": 4, "topShare": 100, "firstTerm": "1224", "lastTerm": "1264" }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6", "name": "James Messina", "quality": 4.493339601162819, "quality_count": 41, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2", "name": "Larry Shapiro", "quality": 4.445878372979523, "quality_count": 81, "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6", "name": "Steven Nadler", "quality": 4.3847532677413925, "quality_count": 46, "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50", "name": "Harry Brighouse", "quality": 4.320598844807286, "quality_count": 53, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6", "name": "Michael Titelbaum", "quality": 4.283047643349683, "quality_count": 37, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89", "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "quality": 4.281023828762943, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3", "name": "Peter Vranas", "quality": 4.042690495429611, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3", "name": "Jesse Steinberg", "quality": 3.976963304883769, "quality_count": 15, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80", "name": "Bruno Whittle", "quality": 3.8548428917732975, "quality_count": 20, "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a", "name": "Annina Loets", "quality": 3.8252641112403607, "quality_count": 13, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd", "name": "Martha Gibson", "quality": 3.746528890116297, "quality_count": 74, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_e8b96304e9a1ede9e5f5bdfd", "name": "Sam Roberts", "quality": 3.7235102700443767, "quality_count": 1, "instructor_url": "/instructors/SAM_ROBERTS" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b", "name": "Emily Fletcher", "quality": 3.6988132223315873, "quality_count": 19, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428", "name": "Paula Gottlieb", "quality": 3.682845014275147, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370", "name": "Farid Masrour", "quality": 3.501602514585476, "quality_count": 26, "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a", "name": "Elliott Sober", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed", "name": "Henry Southgate", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE" }, { "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474", "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2", "name": "John Mackay", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "course_id": "PHILOS 681", "title": "SENIOR HONORS THESIS", "credits_min": 1, "credits_max": 3, "gpa": null, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "James Messina", "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "label": "Larry Shapiro", "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "label": "Steven Nadler", "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "label": "Harry Brighouse", "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "label": "Michael Titelbaum", "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "label": "Peter Vranas", "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" } ] } ], "description": "PHILOS 681 is a mentored study course for senior Philosophy majors to complete honors theses.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6", "name": "James Messina", "quality": 4.493339601162819, "quality_count": 41, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2", "name": "Larry Shapiro", "quality": 4.445878372979523, "quality_count": 81, "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6", "name": "Steven Nadler", "quality": 4.3847532677413925, "quality_count": 46, "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50", "name": "Harry Brighouse", "quality": 4.320598844807286, "quality_count": 53, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6", "name": "Michael Titelbaum", "quality": 4.283047643349683, "quality_count": 37, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89", "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "quality": 4.281023828762943, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3", "name": "Peter Vranas", "quality": 4.042690495429611, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3", "name": "Jesse Steinberg", "quality": 3.976963304883769, "quality_count": 15, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80", "name": "Bruno Whittle", "quality": 3.8548428917732975, "quality_count": 20, "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a", "name": "Annina Loets", "quality": 3.8252641112403607, "quality_count": 13, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7", "name": "Annette Zimmermann", "quality": 3.788478801917079, "quality_count": 17, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3", "name": "Alexander Roberts", "quality": 3.765300540376962, "quality_count": 9, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd", "name": "Martha Gibson", "quality": 3.746528890116297, "quality_count": 74, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b", "name": "Emily Fletcher", "quality": 3.6988132223315873, "quality_count": 19, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428", "name": "Paula Gottlieb", "quality": 3.682845014275147, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370", "name": "Farid Masrour", "quality": 3.501602514585476, "quality_count": 26, "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b", "name": "Aja Watkins", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/AJA_WATKINS" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_0f03a205f447f6b55f01251f", "name": "Elizabeth Brake", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELIZABETH_BRAKE" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a", "name": "Elliott Sober", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed", "name": "Henry Southgate", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb", "name": "Jamie Goodrich", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2", "name": "John Mackay", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY" }, { "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810", "uid": "instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31", "name": "Rob Streiffer", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "course_id": "PHILOS 682", "title": "SENIOR HONORS THESIS", "credits_min": 3, "credits_max": 3, "gpa": 4, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "James Messina", "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "label": "Larry Shapiro", "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "label": "Steven Nadler", "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "label": "Harry Brighouse", "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "label": "Michael Titelbaum", "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "label": "Peter Vranas", "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" } ] } ], "description": "PHILOS 682 is a mentored study course for seniors completing honors theses in the Philosophy major.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 4, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 4, "gpa": 4, "topShare": 100, "firstTerm": "1224", "lastTerm": "1224" }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6", "name": "James Messina", "quality": 4.493339601162819, "quality_count": 41, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2", "name": "Larry Shapiro", "quality": 4.445878372979523, "quality_count": 81, "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6", "name": "Steven Nadler", "quality": 4.3847532677413925, "quality_count": 46, "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50", "name": "Harry Brighouse", "quality": 4.320598844807286, "quality_count": 53, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6", "name": "Michael Titelbaum", "quality": 4.283047643349683, "quality_count": 37, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89", "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "quality": 4.281023828762943, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3", "name": "Peter Vranas", "quality": 4.042690495429611, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3", "name": "Jesse Steinberg", "quality": 3.976963304883769, "quality_count": 15, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80", "name": "Bruno Whittle", "quality": 3.8548428917732975, "quality_count": 20, "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7", "name": "Annette Zimmermann", "quality": 3.788478801917079, "quality_count": 17, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3", "name": "Alexander Roberts", "quality": 3.765300540376962, "quality_count": 9, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd", "name": "Martha Gibson", "quality": 3.746528890116297, "quality_count": 74, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b", "name": "Emily Fletcher", "quality": 3.6988132223315873, "quality_count": 19, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428", "name": "Paula Gottlieb", "quality": 3.682845014275147, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370", "name": "Farid Masrour", "quality": 3.501602514585476, "quality_count": 26, "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a", "name": "Elliott Sober", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed", "name": "Henry Southgate", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb", "name": "Jamie Goodrich", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2", "name": "John Mackay", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY" }, { "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280", "uid": "instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31", "name": "Rob Streiffer", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "course_id": "PHILOS 699", "title": "DIRECTED STUDY", "credits_min": 2, "credits_max": 3, "gpa": null, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "James Messina", "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "label": "Larry Shapiro", "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "label": "Steven Nadler", "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "label": "Harry Brighouse", "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "label": "Michael Titelbaum", "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "label": "Peter Vranas", "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" } ] } ], "description": "PHILOS 699 is a directed study course allowing independent research arranged with a faculty member.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6", "name": "James Messina", "quality": 4.493339601162819, "quality_count": 41, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2", "name": "Larry Shapiro", "quality": 4.445878372979523, "quality_count": 81, "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6", "name": "Steven Nadler", "quality": 4.3847532677413925, "quality_count": 46, "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50", "name": "Harry Brighouse", "quality": 4.320598844807286, "quality_count": 53, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6", "name": "Michael Titelbaum", "quality": 4.283047643349683, "quality_count": 37, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89", "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "quality": 4.281023828762943, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3", "name": "Peter Vranas", "quality": 4.042690495429611, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3", "name": "Jesse Steinberg", "quality": 3.976963304883769, "quality_count": 15, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80", "name": "Bruno Whittle", "quality": 3.8548428917732975, "quality_count": 20, "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd", "name": "Martha Gibson", "quality": 3.746528890116297, "quality_count": 74, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b", "name": "Emily Fletcher", "quality": 3.6988132223315873, "quality_count": 19, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428", "name": "Paula Gottlieb", "quality": 3.682845014275147, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370", "name": "Farid Masrour", "quality": 3.501602514585476, "quality_count": 26, "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a", "name": "Elliott Sober", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed", "name": "Henry Southgate", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE" }, { "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076", "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2", "name": "John Mackay", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "course_id": "PHILOS 990", "title": "RESEARCH AND THESIS", "credits_min": 2, "credits_max": 9, "gpa": null, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "James Messina", "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "label": "Larry Shapiro", "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "label": "Steven Nadler", "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "label": "Harry Brighouse", "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "label": "Michael Titelbaum", "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "label": "Peter Vranas", "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" } ] } ], "description": "PHILOS 990 is a graduate research and thesis course involving individual mentored study arranged with a faculty member.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6", "name": "James Messina", "quality": 4.493339601162819, "quality_count": 41, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2", "name": "Larry Shapiro", "quality": 4.445878372979523, "quality_count": 81, "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6", "name": "Steven Nadler", "quality": 4.3847532677413925, "quality_count": 46, "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50", "name": "Harry Brighouse", "quality": 4.320598844807286, "quality_count": 53, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6", "name": "Michael Titelbaum", "quality": 4.283047643349683, "quality_count": 37, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89", "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "quality": 4.281023828762943, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3", "name": "Peter Vranas", "quality": 4.042690495429611, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3", "name": "Jesse Steinberg", "quality": 3.976963304883769, "quality_count": 15, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80", "name": "Bruno Whittle", "quality": 3.8548428917732975, "quality_count": 20, "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a", "name": "Annina Loets", "quality": 3.8252641112403607, "quality_count": 13, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7", "name": "Annette Zimmermann", "quality": 3.788478801917079, "quality_count": 17, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_c48098ca387a2eedac71f822", "name": "Alexander Meehan", "quality": 3.7677486268372764, "quality_count": 5, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_MEEHAN" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3", "name": "Alexander Roberts", "quality": 3.765300540376962, "quality_count": 9, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd", "name": "Martha Gibson", "quality": 3.746528890116297, "quality_count": 74, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b", "name": "Emily Fletcher", "quality": 3.6988132223315873, "quality_count": 19, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428", "name": "Paula Gottlieb", "quality": 3.682845014275147, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370", "name": "Farid Masrour", "quality": 3.501602514585476, "quality_count": 26, "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b", "name": "Aja Watkins", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/AJA_WATKINS" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_0f03a205f447f6b55f01251f", "name": "Elizabeth Brake", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELIZABETH_BRAKE" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a", "name": "Elliott Sober", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed", "name": "Henry Southgate", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_e39149f0f2d81ed7d47ba445", "name": "J. Kelleher", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/J_KELLEHER" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb", "name": "Jamie Goodrich", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2", "name": "John Mackay", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY" }, { "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3", "uid": "instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31", "name": "Rob Streiffer", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "course_id": "PHILOS 999", "title": "INDEPENDENT WORK", "credits_min": 2, "credits_max": 9, "gpa": 4, "badges": [ { "id": "rated-teacher", "label": "Highly rated instructor", "tone": "positive", "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.", "sources": [ { "label": "James Messina", "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "label": "Larry Shapiro", "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "label": "Steven Nadler", "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "label": "Harry Brighouse", "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "label": "Michael Titelbaum", "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "label": "Peter Vranas", "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" } ] } ], "description": "PHILOS 999 is an individual mentored study course for graduate students arranged with a faculty member.", "discovery": { "term": "1272", "offered": true, "history": { "counts": [ 4, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 4, "gpa": 4, "topShare": 100, "firstTerm": "1224", "lastTerm": "1224" }, "instructors": [ { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6", "name": "James Messina", "quality": 4.493339601162819, "quality_count": 41, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2", "name": "Larry Shapiro", "quality": 4.445878372979523, "quality_count": 81, "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6", "name": "Steven Nadler", "quality": 4.3847532677413925, "quality_count": 46, "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50", "name": "Harry Brighouse", "quality": 4.320598844807286, "quality_count": 53, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6", "name": "Michael Titelbaum", "quality": 4.283047643349683, "quality_count": 37, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89", "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau", "quality": 4.281023828762943, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3", "name": "Peter Vranas", "quality": 4.042690495429611, "quality_count": 52, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3", "name": "Jesse Steinberg", "quality": 3.976963304883769, "quality_count": 15, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80", "name": "Bruno Whittle", "quality": 3.8548428917732975, "quality_count": 20, "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a", "name": "Annina Loets", "quality": 3.8252641112403607, "quality_count": 13, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7", "name": "Annette Zimmermann", "quality": 3.788478801917079, "quality_count": 17, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_c48098ca387a2eedac71f822", "name": "Alexander Meehan", "quality": 3.7677486268372764, "quality_count": 5, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_MEEHAN" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3", "name": "Alexander Roberts", "quality": 3.765300540376962, "quality_count": 9, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd", "name": "Martha Gibson", "quality": 3.746528890116297, "quality_count": 74, "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b", "name": "Emily Fletcher", "quality": 3.6988132223315873, "quality_count": 19, "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428", "name": "Paula Gottlieb", "quality": 3.682845014275147, "quality_count": 27, "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370", "name": "Farid Masrour", "quality": 3.501602514585476, "quality_count": 26, "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b", "name": "Aja Watkins", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/AJA_WATKINS" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a", "name": "Elliott Sober", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed", "name": "Henry Southgate", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_e39149f0f2d81ed7d47ba445", "name": "J. Kelleher", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/J_KELLEHER" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb", "name": "Jamie Goodrich", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2", "name": "John Mackay", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY" }, { "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556", "uid": "instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31", "name": "Rob Streiffer", "quality": null, "quality_count": null, "instructor_url": "/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER" } ], "instructorHistory": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "courseComparison": { "counts": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ], "count": 0, "gpa": null, "topShare": null }, "claim": null, "reviewFiles": [] } } ] ``` ## reviews ### items ```json [ { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:12:17.664313+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTQxNTQ5NTIx", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "course_label": "PHIL241", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2025-08-05 15:35:31 +0000 UTC", "comment": "She's a good professor. Tries to get the class engaged with the material. Good intro philosophy class", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "quality_rating": 4, "difficulty_rating": 1 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:12:17.664313+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTQwNTkwMzQy", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "course_label": "PHIL430", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2025-01-23 01:41:12 +0000 UTC", "comment": "Paula was a fantastic professor and I enjoyed her class. But she grades with swing grades, so if you're not in the boundaries of a grade, you will be rounded down. For an A, the grading scale is a 94-95 out of 95, or a 98% or above. While I enjoyed the class, this ensured that while I got above a 95% on all papers, I received a B in the class.", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "quality_rating": 3, "difficulty_rating": 3 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:12:17.664313+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTQwMjk3MDMz", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "course_label": "PHILOS430", "course_id": "PHILOS 430", "course_uid": "course_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116", "review_date": "2024-12-14 19:01:00 +0000 UTC", "comment": "Take this class if you're a Philos major, don't if you're not. It is not as real-world applicable as modern philos, which should be obvious. Paula is funny, but granted a little boring, yet very passionate. Her swing grade system is reasonable, but you need to do well for an A. Her tutorial system is very fun: papers with a discussion about it.", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "quality_rating": 5, "difficulty_rating": 2 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:12:17.664313+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM4NjkwNDQ5", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "course_label": "PHILO430", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2023-12-15 15:47:16 +0000 UTC", "comment": "This class was only made more enjoyable by somebody as knowledgeable and passionate about ancient greek philosophy as Paula. While lectures may seem to run slow, she nonetheless follows a clear and orderly mode of instruction with the occasional deadpan humor in the mix. Really immerse yourself in the readings, and you will do great come tutorials.", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "quality_rating": 5, "difficulty_rating": 3 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:12:17.664313+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM4NjQyOTA3", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "course_label": "PHILOS430", "course_id": "PHILOS 430", "course_uid": "course_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116", "review_date": "2023-12-13 03:41:39 +0000 UTC", "comment": "She wasn't my favorite professor in the department. Her lectures are pretty boring, and her voice honestly put me to sleep most days. I don't like her \"swing\" grade strategy or revising the grading scale. I just wish she counted attendance and we were graded normally on the papers. The ancients are pretty underwhelming, too.", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "quality_rating": 2, "difficulty_rating": 3 }, { "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:12:17.664313+00:00", "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4", "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM3MzYzNDEw", "source_instructor_id": "rmp:589692", "instructor_name": "Paula Gottlieb", "course_label": "PHIL430", "course_id": null, "course_uid": null, "review_date": "2023-01-21 18:30:31 +0000 UTC", "comment": "Lectures are impressively boring and the only reason to show up is for the participation grade. I signed in online for lectures but was never present at my computer thereduring. If you enjoy philosophy that has practical implications on your life and can improve it in some manner, avoid this class. ", "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/589692", "quality_rating": 1, "difficulty_rating": 1 } ] ``` ### total 27 ### page 1 ### courses | course\_uid | course\_id | | -------------------------------- | ---------- | | course\_7a64c9e06bf089b093eb0116 | PHILOS 430 | ### matched true ## social Image true