# Michael Titelbaum — Courses & Reviews | UW–Madison

[View on UW Courses](https://uwcourses.com/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM)

## Dataset

### revision

e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349

### repository

twangodev/uwcourses

### schema version

6

### importer version

7

### projection id

52a78527ff09011d88cb04c7d43867d9fbfec2930bf1dd2ec359ebd2844e0b07

### observed at

2026-09-07T15:55:43.033547+00:00

### built at

2026-09-10T19:50:42.743001+00:00

### courses

8951

### current instructors

5754

### limited

false

### terms

* 1272
* 1264
* 1262
* 1254
* 1252
* 1244
* 1242
* 1234
* 1232
* 1224
* 1222
* 1212
* 1204
* 1202
* 1194
* 1192
* 1184
* 1182
* 1174
* 1172
* 1164
* 1162
* 1154
* 1152
* 1144
* 1142
* 1134
* 1132
* 1124
* 1122
* 1114
* 1112
* 1104
* 1102
* 1094
* 1092
* 1084
* 1082
* 1074
* 1072

### term

1272

### departments

| subject   | count |
| --------- | ----- |
| AAE       | 90    |
| ABT       | 20    |
| ACCTIS    | 36    |
| ACTSCI    | 14    |
| AFAERO    | 10    |
| AFRICAN   | 87    |
| AFROAMER  | 71    |
| AGROECOL  | 21    |
| AMERIND   | 53    |
| ANAT\&PHY | 7     |
| ANATOMY   | 2     |
| ANESTHES  | 8     |
| ANSCI     | 57    |
| ANTHRO    | 95    |
| ART       | 125   |
| ARTED     | 10    |
| ARTHIST   | 121   |
| ASIALANG  | 129   |
| ASIAN     | 109   |
| ASIANAM   | 28    |
| ASTRON    | 38    |
| ATMOCN    | 69    |
| BIOCHEM   | 51    |
| BIOCORE   | 10    |
| BIOLOGY   | 14    |
| BIOMDSCI  | 18    |
| BME       | 66    |
| BMI       | 41    |
| BMOLCHEM  | 10    |
| BOTANY    | 69    |
| BSE       | 44    |
| C\&ESOC   | 73    |
| CBE       | 48    |
| CHEM      | 101   |
| CHICLA    | 52    |
| CIVENGR   | 133   |
| CLASSICS  | 47    |
| CNP       | 10    |
| CNSRSCI   | 50    |
| COMARTS   | 137   |
| COMPBIO   | 15    |
| COMPLIT   | 11    |
| COMPSCI   | 138   |
| COUNPSY   | 78    |
| CRB       | 19    |
| CS\&D     | 71    |
| CSCS      | 40    |
| CURRIC    | 193   |
| DANCE     | 93    |
| DERM      | 8     |
| DS        | 88    |
| DYSCI     | 35    |
| ECE       | 155   |
| ECON      | 145   |
| EDPOL     | 114   |
| EDPSYCH   | 97    |
| ELPA      | 70    |
| EMA       | 53    |
| EMERMED   | 17    |
| ENGL      | 206   |
| ENTOM     | 40    |
| ENVIRST   | 148   |
| EP        | 15    |
| EPD       | 67    |
| ESL       | 16    |
| F\&WECOL  | 60    |
| FAMMED    | 22    |
| FINANCE   | 50    |
| FOLKLORE  | 40    |
| FOODSCI   | 43    |
| FRENCH    | 63    |
| GEN\&WS   | 145   |
| GENBUS    | 72    |
| GENECSLR  | 17    |
| GENETICS  | 60    |
| GEOG      | 113   |
| GEOSCI    | 83    |
| GERMAN    | 82    |
| GLE       | 48    |
| GNS       | 38    |
| GREEK     | 27    |
| HDFS      | 41    |
| HEBR-BIB  | 13    |
| HEBR-MOD  | 10    |
| HISTORY   | 233   |
| HISTSCI   | 56    |
| HONCOL    | 13    |
| ILS       | 43    |
| INFOSYS   | 9     |
| INTEGART  | 7     |
| INTEGSCI  | 22    |
| INTER-AG  | 18    |
| INTER-HE  | 11    |
| INTER-LS  | 22    |
| INTEREGR  | 16    |
| INTLBUS   | 21    |
| INTLST    | 50    |
| ISYE      | 83    |
| ITALIAN   | 53    |
| JEWISH    | 56    |
| JOURN     | 88    |
| KINES     | 128   |
| LACIS     | 26    |
| LANDARC   | 61    |
| LATIN     | 24    |
| LAW       | 120   |
| LEGALST   | 48    |
| LINGUIS   | 35    |
| LIS       | 89    |
| LITTRANS  | 78    |
| LSC       | 52    |
| M\&ENVTOX | 7     |
| MARKETNG  | 62    |
| MATH      | 153   |
| MDGENET   | 8     |
| ME        | 130   |
| MEDHIST   | 43    |
| MEDICINE  | 60    |
| MEDIEVAL  | 32    |
| MEDPHYS   | 39    |
| MEDSC-M   | 29    |
| MEDSC-V   | 41    |
| MHR       | 68    |
| MICROBIO  | 45    |
| MILSCI    | 16    |
| MM\&I     | 22    |
| MOLBIOL   | 6     |
| MS\&E     | 59    |
| MUSIC     | 165   |
| MUSPERF   | 126   |
| NAVSCI    | 20    |
| NE        | 44    |
| NEURODPT  | 11    |
| NEUROL    | 7     |
| NEURSURG  | 4     |
| NTP       | 11    |
| NURSING   | 111   |
| NUTRSCI   | 65    |
| OBS\&GYN  | 18    |
| OCCTHER   | 39    |
| ONCOLOGY  | 14    |
| OPHTHALM  | 5     |
| OTM       | 43    |
| PATH      | 34    |
| PATH-BIO  | 29    |
| PEDIAT    | 26    |
| PHARMACY  | 31    |
| PHILOS    | 77    |
| PHMCOL-M  | 11    |
| PHMPRAC   | 45    |
| PHMSCI    | 60    |
| PHYASST   | 37    |
| PHYSICS   | 88    |
| PHYSIOL   | 3     |
| PHYTHER   | 37    |
| PLANTSCI  | 52    |
| PLPATH    | 35    |
| POLISCI   | 192   |
| POPHLTH   | 58    |
| PORTUG    | 33    |
| PSYCH     | 101   |
| PSYCHIAT  | 22    |
| PUBAFFR   | 54    |
| PUBLHLTH  | 23    |
| RADIOL    | 11    |
| REALEST   | 41    |
| RELIGST   | 90    |
| RHABMED   | 9     |
| RMI       | 24    |
| RP\&SE    | 102   |
| S\&APHM   | 17    |
| SCANDST   | 73    |
| SLAVIC    | 89    |
| SOC       | 149   |
| SOCWORK   | 87    |
| SOILSCI   | 46    |
| SPANISH   | 83    |
| SRMED     | 21    |
| STAT      | 94    |
| STDYABRD  | 52    |
| STS       | 8     |
| SURGERY   | 25    |
| SURGSCI   | 33    |
| THEATRE   | 91    |
| URBRPL    | 60    |
| UROLOGY   | 5     |
| ZOOLOGY   | 89    |

## instructor

### instructor uid

instructor\_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6

### source

enrollment

### source instructor id

titelbaum

### identity basis

netid

### identity status

source\_identified

### name

Michael Titelbaum

### email

TITELBAUM\@WISC.EDU

### first observed at

2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00

### last observed at

2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00

### ratings

#### review count

37

#### quality

4.62

#### difficulty

3.03

#### quality count

37

#### difficulty count

37

#### profile id

rmp:1267337

#### source url

<https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1267337>

#### match basis

exact\_name

#### observed at

2026-09-07 16:17:29.533919+00:00

#### courses

##### course 9135c71251486b5b91c37031

###### review count

1

###### quality

5

###### difficulty

3

###### quality count

1

###### difficulty count

1

#### bayesian quality

4.283047643349683

#### prior mean

3.6596857835465957

#### prior weight

20

### current

true

### courses

| course\_uid                      | course\_id | title                      | credits\_min | credits\_max | gpa   |
| -------------------------------- | ---------- | -------------------------- | ------------ | ------------ | ----- |
| course\_23d2425c4374643d474e6aa1 | PHILOS 903 | SEMINAR: EPISTEMOLOGY      | 3            | 3            | 3.776 |
| course\_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3 | PHILOS 990 | RESEARCH AND THESIS        | 2            | 9            |       |
| course\_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076 | PHILOS 699 | DIRECTED STUDY             | 2            | 3            |       |
| course\_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556 | PHILOS 999 | INDEPENDENT WORK           | 2            | 9            | 4     |
| course\_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280 | PHILOS 682 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS       | 3            | 3            | 4     |
| course\_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7 | PHILOS 101 | INTRODUCTION TO PHILOSOPHY | 3            | 4            | 3.304 |
| course\_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810 | PHILOS 681 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS       | 1            | 3            |       |
| course\_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474 | PHILOS 599 | DIRECTED STUDY             | 1            | 3            | 4     |
| course\_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4 | PHILOS 701 | READING SEMINAR            | 3            | 3            | 4     |
| course\_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b | PHILOS 799 | DIRECTED STUDY             | 1            | 3            |       |

### revision

e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349

### instructor url

/instructors/MICHAEL\_TITELBAUM

## history

| term | course\_uid                      | course\_id | title                      |
| ---- | -------------------------------- | ---------- | -------------------------- |
| 1272 | course\_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7 | PHILOS 101 | INTRODUCTION TO PHILOSOPHY |
| 1272 | course\_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474 | PHILOS 599 | DIRECTED STUDY             |
| 1272 | course\_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810 | PHILOS 681 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS       |
| 1272 | course\_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280 | PHILOS 682 | SENIOR HONORS THESIS       |
| 1272 | course\_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076 | PHILOS 699 | DIRECTED STUDY             |
| 1272 | course\_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4 | PHILOS 701 | READING SEMINAR            |
| 1272 | course\_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b | PHILOS 799 | DIRECTED STUDY             |
| 1272 | course\_23d2425c4374643d474e6aa1 | PHILOS 903 | SEMINAR: EPISTEMOLOGY      |
| 1272 | course\_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3 | PHILOS 990 | RESEARCH AND THESIS        |
| 1272 | course\_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556 | PHILOS 999 | INDEPENDENT WORK           |

## timeline

| term | courses |
| ---- | ------- |
| 1272 | 10      |

## term

1272

## courses

```json
[
  {
    "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 101",
    "title": "INTRODUCTION TO PHILOSOPHY",
    "credits_min": 3,
    "credits_max": 4,
    "gpa": 3.304,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "James Messina",
            "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
          },
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 101 introduces students to various philosophical questions and the strategies philosophers use to address them.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          2013,
          906,
          476,
          171,
          90,
          23,
          39
        ],
        "count": 3718,
        "gpa": 3.5722162452931685,
        "topShare": 78.50995158687466,
        "firstTerm": "1224",
        "lastTerm": "1264"
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6",
          "name": "James Messina",
          "quality": 4.493339601162819,
          "quality_count": 41,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_3496db2cb423d564673371ca",
          "name": "Arun Baxter",
          "quality": 3.9708783581826634,
          "quality_count": 7,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ARUN_BAXTER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80",
          "name": "Bruno Whittle",
          "quality": 3.8548428917732975,
          "quality_count": 20,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a",
          "name": "Annina Loets",
          "quality": 3.8252641112403607,
          "quality_count": 13,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3",
          "name": "Alexander Roberts",
          "quality": 3.765300540376962,
          "quality_count": 9,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_af3b3ddda0123f48517b1b9a",
          "name": "Anton Dolmatov",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANTON_DOLMATOV"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_97a9d4017a7ead9113b1e885",
          "name": "Cristian Vulpe",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/CRISTIAN_VULPE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_569d277bf5134c33bdb46edb",
          "name": "Mary-Kate Boyle",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARY-KATE_BOYLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7",
          "uid": "instructor_5d77f5ae6d3e161fb2c04761",
          "name": "Will Siegmund",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/WILL_SIEGMUND"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": {
        "citations": [
          {
            "course_id": "PHILOS 101",
            "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
            "section_number": 3,
            "source_course_id": "c23d7b1d-4add-3dd4-a9e5-47d56b05aa42",
            "source_record": {
              "entity_id": "c23d7b1d-4add-3dd4-a9e5-47d56b05aa42",
              "file": "tables/observations.parquet",
              "kind": "grades",
              "source": "madgrades"
            },
            "table": "section_grades_latest",
            "term_id": "1262",
            "type": "grade"
          }
        ],
        "text": "Recent recorded grades — Fall 2025: 3.74 GPA, 88.1% A/AB (n=67 letter grades)."
      },
      "reviewFiles": [
        "/data/e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349/reviews/course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7-0.json"
      ]
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 599",
    "title": "DIRECTED STUDY",
    "credits_min": 1,
    "credits_max": 3,
    "gpa": 4,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "James Messina",
            "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
          },
          {
            "label": "Larry Shapiro",
            "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
          },
          {
            "label": "Steven Nadler",
            "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
          },
          {
            "label": "Harry Brighouse",
            "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
          },
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          },
          {
            "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
            "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
          },
          {
            "label": "Peter Vranas",
            "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 599 is a directed study course allowing students to pursue independent research or study topics arranged with a faculty member.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          9,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 9,
        "gpa": 4,
        "topShare": 100,
        "firstTerm": "1224",
        "lastTerm": "1264"
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6",
          "name": "James Messina",
          "quality": 4.493339601162819,
          "quality_count": 41,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2",
          "name": "Larry Shapiro",
          "quality": 4.445878372979523,
          "quality_count": 81,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6",
          "name": "Steven Nadler",
          "quality": 4.3847532677413925,
          "quality_count": 46,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50",
          "name": "Harry Brighouse",
          "quality": 4.320598844807286,
          "quality_count": 53,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89",
          "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
          "quality": 4.281023828762943,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3",
          "name": "Peter Vranas",
          "quality": 4.042690495429611,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3",
          "name": "Jesse Steinberg",
          "quality": 3.976963304883769,
          "quality_count": 15,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80",
          "name": "Bruno Whittle",
          "quality": 3.8548428917732975,
          "quality_count": 20,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a",
          "name": "Annina Loets",
          "quality": 3.8252641112403607,
          "quality_count": 13,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd",
          "name": "Martha Gibson",
          "quality": 3.746528890116297,
          "quality_count": 74,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_e8b96304e9a1ede9e5f5bdfd",
          "name": "Sam Roberts",
          "quality": 3.7235102700443767,
          "quality_count": 1,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/SAM_ROBERTS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b",
          "name": "Emily Fletcher",
          "quality": 3.6988132223315873,
          "quality_count": 19,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428",
          "name": "Paula Gottlieb",
          "quality": 3.682845014275147,
          "quality_count": 27,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370",
          "name": "Farid Masrour",
          "quality": 3.501602514585476,
          "quality_count": 26,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a",
          "name": "Elliott Sober",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed",
          "name": "Henry Southgate",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474",
          "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2",
          "name": "John Mackay",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": null,
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 681",
    "title": "SENIOR HONORS THESIS",
    "credits_min": 1,
    "credits_max": 3,
    "gpa": null,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "James Messina",
            "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
          },
          {
            "label": "Larry Shapiro",
            "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
          },
          {
            "label": "Steven Nadler",
            "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
          },
          {
            "label": "Harry Brighouse",
            "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
          },
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          },
          {
            "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
            "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
          },
          {
            "label": "Peter Vranas",
            "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 681 is a mentored study course for senior Philosophy majors to complete honors theses.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6",
          "name": "James Messina",
          "quality": 4.493339601162819,
          "quality_count": 41,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2",
          "name": "Larry Shapiro",
          "quality": 4.445878372979523,
          "quality_count": 81,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6",
          "name": "Steven Nadler",
          "quality": 4.3847532677413925,
          "quality_count": 46,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50",
          "name": "Harry Brighouse",
          "quality": 4.320598844807286,
          "quality_count": 53,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89",
          "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
          "quality": 4.281023828762943,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3",
          "name": "Peter Vranas",
          "quality": 4.042690495429611,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3",
          "name": "Jesse Steinberg",
          "quality": 3.976963304883769,
          "quality_count": 15,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80",
          "name": "Bruno Whittle",
          "quality": 3.8548428917732975,
          "quality_count": 20,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a",
          "name": "Annina Loets",
          "quality": 3.8252641112403607,
          "quality_count": 13,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7",
          "name": "Annette Zimmermann",
          "quality": 3.788478801917079,
          "quality_count": 17,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3",
          "name": "Alexander Roberts",
          "quality": 3.765300540376962,
          "quality_count": 9,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd",
          "name": "Martha Gibson",
          "quality": 3.746528890116297,
          "quality_count": 74,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b",
          "name": "Emily Fletcher",
          "quality": 3.6988132223315873,
          "quality_count": 19,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428",
          "name": "Paula Gottlieb",
          "quality": 3.682845014275147,
          "quality_count": 27,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370",
          "name": "Farid Masrour",
          "quality": 3.501602514585476,
          "quality_count": 26,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b",
          "name": "Aja Watkins",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/AJA_WATKINS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_0f03a205f447f6b55f01251f",
          "name": "Elizabeth Brake",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELIZABETH_BRAKE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a",
          "name": "Elliott Sober",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed",
          "name": "Henry Southgate",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb",
          "name": "Jamie Goodrich",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2",
          "name": "John Mackay",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810",
          "uid": "instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31",
          "name": "Rob Streiffer",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": null,
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 682",
    "title": "SENIOR HONORS THESIS",
    "credits_min": 3,
    "credits_max": 3,
    "gpa": 4,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "James Messina",
            "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
          },
          {
            "label": "Larry Shapiro",
            "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
          },
          {
            "label": "Steven Nadler",
            "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
          },
          {
            "label": "Harry Brighouse",
            "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
          },
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          },
          {
            "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
            "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
          },
          {
            "label": "Peter Vranas",
            "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 682 is a mentored study course for seniors completing honors theses in the Philosophy major.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          4,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 4,
        "gpa": 4,
        "topShare": 100,
        "firstTerm": "1224",
        "lastTerm": "1224"
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6",
          "name": "James Messina",
          "quality": 4.493339601162819,
          "quality_count": 41,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2",
          "name": "Larry Shapiro",
          "quality": 4.445878372979523,
          "quality_count": 81,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6",
          "name": "Steven Nadler",
          "quality": 4.3847532677413925,
          "quality_count": 46,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50",
          "name": "Harry Brighouse",
          "quality": 4.320598844807286,
          "quality_count": 53,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89",
          "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
          "quality": 4.281023828762943,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3",
          "name": "Peter Vranas",
          "quality": 4.042690495429611,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3",
          "name": "Jesse Steinberg",
          "quality": 3.976963304883769,
          "quality_count": 15,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80",
          "name": "Bruno Whittle",
          "quality": 3.8548428917732975,
          "quality_count": 20,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7",
          "name": "Annette Zimmermann",
          "quality": 3.788478801917079,
          "quality_count": 17,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3",
          "name": "Alexander Roberts",
          "quality": 3.765300540376962,
          "quality_count": 9,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd",
          "name": "Martha Gibson",
          "quality": 3.746528890116297,
          "quality_count": 74,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b",
          "name": "Emily Fletcher",
          "quality": 3.6988132223315873,
          "quality_count": 19,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428",
          "name": "Paula Gottlieb",
          "quality": 3.682845014275147,
          "quality_count": 27,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370",
          "name": "Farid Masrour",
          "quality": 3.501602514585476,
          "quality_count": 26,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a",
          "name": "Elliott Sober",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed",
          "name": "Henry Southgate",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb",
          "name": "Jamie Goodrich",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2",
          "name": "John Mackay",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280",
          "uid": "instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31",
          "name": "Rob Streiffer",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": null,
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 699",
    "title": "DIRECTED STUDY",
    "credits_min": 2,
    "credits_max": 3,
    "gpa": null,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "James Messina",
            "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
          },
          {
            "label": "Larry Shapiro",
            "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
          },
          {
            "label": "Steven Nadler",
            "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
          },
          {
            "label": "Harry Brighouse",
            "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
          },
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          },
          {
            "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
            "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
          },
          {
            "label": "Peter Vranas",
            "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 699 is a directed study course allowing independent research arranged with a faculty member.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6",
          "name": "James Messina",
          "quality": 4.493339601162819,
          "quality_count": 41,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2",
          "name": "Larry Shapiro",
          "quality": 4.445878372979523,
          "quality_count": 81,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6",
          "name": "Steven Nadler",
          "quality": 4.3847532677413925,
          "quality_count": 46,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50",
          "name": "Harry Brighouse",
          "quality": 4.320598844807286,
          "quality_count": 53,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89",
          "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
          "quality": 4.281023828762943,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3",
          "name": "Peter Vranas",
          "quality": 4.042690495429611,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3",
          "name": "Jesse Steinberg",
          "quality": 3.976963304883769,
          "quality_count": 15,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80",
          "name": "Bruno Whittle",
          "quality": 3.8548428917732975,
          "quality_count": 20,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd",
          "name": "Martha Gibson",
          "quality": 3.746528890116297,
          "quality_count": 74,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b",
          "name": "Emily Fletcher",
          "quality": 3.6988132223315873,
          "quality_count": 19,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428",
          "name": "Paula Gottlieb",
          "quality": 3.682845014275147,
          "quality_count": 27,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370",
          "name": "Farid Masrour",
          "quality": 3.501602514585476,
          "quality_count": 26,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a",
          "name": "Elliott Sober",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed",
          "name": "Henry Southgate",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076",
          "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2",
          "name": "John Mackay",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": null,
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 701",
    "title": "READING SEMINAR",
    "credits_min": 3,
    "credits_max": 3,
    "gpa": 4,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 701 is a reading seminar that examines select topics in philosophy.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          11,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 11,
        "gpa": 4,
        "topShare": 100,
        "firstTerm": "1224",
        "lastTerm": "1232"
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4",
          "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd",
          "name": "Martha Gibson",
          "quality": 3.746528890116297,
          "quality_count": 74,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4",
          "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370",
          "name": "Farid Masrour",
          "quality": 3.501602514585476,
          "quality_count": 26,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4",
          "uid": "instructor_e36586ff1ce5d9f82bf1ddc9",
          "name": "Sophia Dandelet",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/SOPHIA_DANDELET"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": null,
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 799",
    "title": "DIRECTED STUDY",
    "credits_min": 1,
    "credits_max": 3,
    "gpa": null,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "James Messina",
            "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
          },
          {
            "label": "Steven Nadler",
            "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
          },
          {
            "label": "Harry Brighouse",
            "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
          },
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          },
          {
            "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
            "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 799 is a directed study course allowing students to conduct independent research or study arranged with a faculty member.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6",
          "name": "James Messina",
          "quality": 4.493339601162819,
          "quality_count": 41,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6",
          "name": "Steven Nadler",
          "quality": 4.3847532677413925,
          "quality_count": 46,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50",
          "name": "Harry Brighouse",
          "quality": 4.320598844807286,
          "quality_count": 53,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89",
          "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
          "quality": 4.281023828762943,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3",
          "name": "Jesse Steinberg",
          "quality": 3.976963304883769,
          "quality_count": 15,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80",
          "name": "Bruno Whittle",
          "quality": 3.8548428917732975,
          "quality_count": 20,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3",
          "name": "Alexander Roberts",
          "quality": 3.765300540376962,
          "quality_count": 9,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b",
          "name": "Emily Fletcher",
          "quality": 3.6988132223315873,
          "quality_count": 19,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370",
          "name": "Farid Masrour",
          "quality": 3.501602514585476,
          "quality_count": 26,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a",
          "name": "Elliott Sober",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed",
          "name": "Henry Southgate",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_fc7f51f78b28005b0e94585b",
          "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb",
          "name": "Jamie Goodrich",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": null,
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_23d2425c4374643d474e6aa1",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 903",
    "title": "SEMINAR: EPISTEMOLOGY",
    "credits_min": 3,
    "credits_max": 3,
    "gpa": 3.776,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "A graduate seminar focused on the philosophical study of epistemology.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          3,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 3,
        "gpa": 4,
        "topShare": 100,
        "firstTerm": "1244",
        "lastTerm": "1244"
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_23d2425c4374643d474e6aa1",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_23d2425c4374643d474e6aa1",
          "uid": "instructor_e36586ff1ce5d9f82bf1ddc9",
          "name": "Sophia Dandelet",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/SOPHIA_DANDELET"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": {
        "citations": [
          {
            "course_id": "PHILOS 903",
            "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
            "section_number": 1,
            "source_course_id": "fadd262d-f8ec-3a17-b94a-5ab612a490cd",
            "source_record": {
              "entity_id": "fadd262d-f8ec-3a17-b94a-5ab612a490cd",
              "file": "tables/observations.parquet",
              "kind": "grades",
              "source": "madgrades"
            },
            "table": "section_grades_latest",
            "term_id": "1134",
            "type": "grade"
          },
          {
            "course_id": "PHILOS 903",
            "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
            "section_number": 1,
            "source_course_id": "fadd262d-f8ec-3a17-b94a-5ab612a490cd",
            "source_record": {
              "entity_id": "fadd262d-f8ec-3a17-b94a-5ab612a490cd",
              "file": "tables/observations.parquet",
              "kind": "grades",
              "source": "madgrades"
            },
            "table": "section_grades_latest",
            "term_id": "1194",
            "type": "grade"
          },
          {
            "course_id": "PHILOS 903",
            "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
            "section_number": 1,
            "source_course_id": "fadd262d-f8ec-3a17-b94a-5ab612a490cd",
            "source_record": {
              "entity_id": "fadd262d-f8ec-3a17-b94a-5ab612a490cd",
              "file": "tables/observations.parquet",
              "kind": "grades",
              "source": "madgrades"
            },
            "table": "section_grades_latest",
            "term_id": "1244",
            "type": "grade"
          }
        ],
        "text": "Recent recorded grades — Spring 2013: 3.96 GPA, 100.0% A/AB (n=12 letter grades); Spring 2019: 3.70 GPA, 80.0% A/AB (n=5 letter grades); Spring 2024: 4.00 GPA, 100.0% A/AB (n=3 letter grades)."
      },
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 990",
    "title": "RESEARCH AND THESIS",
    "credits_min": 2,
    "credits_max": 9,
    "gpa": null,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "James Messina",
            "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
          },
          {
            "label": "Larry Shapiro",
            "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
          },
          {
            "label": "Steven Nadler",
            "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
          },
          {
            "label": "Harry Brighouse",
            "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
          },
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          },
          {
            "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
            "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
          },
          {
            "label": "Peter Vranas",
            "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 990 is a graduate research and thesis course involving individual mentored study arranged with a faculty member.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6",
          "name": "James Messina",
          "quality": 4.493339601162819,
          "quality_count": 41,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2",
          "name": "Larry Shapiro",
          "quality": 4.445878372979523,
          "quality_count": 81,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6",
          "name": "Steven Nadler",
          "quality": 4.3847532677413925,
          "quality_count": 46,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50",
          "name": "Harry Brighouse",
          "quality": 4.320598844807286,
          "quality_count": 53,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89",
          "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
          "quality": 4.281023828762943,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3",
          "name": "Peter Vranas",
          "quality": 4.042690495429611,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3",
          "name": "Jesse Steinberg",
          "quality": 3.976963304883769,
          "quality_count": 15,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80",
          "name": "Bruno Whittle",
          "quality": 3.8548428917732975,
          "quality_count": 20,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a",
          "name": "Annina Loets",
          "quality": 3.8252641112403607,
          "quality_count": 13,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7",
          "name": "Annette Zimmermann",
          "quality": 3.788478801917079,
          "quality_count": 17,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_c48098ca387a2eedac71f822",
          "name": "Alexander Meehan",
          "quality": 3.7677486268372764,
          "quality_count": 5,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_MEEHAN"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3",
          "name": "Alexander Roberts",
          "quality": 3.765300540376962,
          "quality_count": 9,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd",
          "name": "Martha Gibson",
          "quality": 3.746528890116297,
          "quality_count": 74,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b",
          "name": "Emily Fletcher",
          "quality": 3.6988132223315873,
          "quality_count": 19,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428",
          "name": "Paula Gottlieb",
          "quality": 3.682845014275147,
          "quality_count": 27,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370",
          "name": "Farid Masrour",
          "quality": 3.501602514585476,
          "quality_count": 26,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b",
          "name": "Aja Watkins",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/AJA_WATKINS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_0f03a205f447f6b55f01251f",
          "name": "Elizabeth Brake",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELIZABETH_BRAKE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a",
          "name": "Elliott Sober",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed",
          "name": "Henry Southgate",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_e39149f0f2d81ed7d47ba445",
          "name": "J. Kelleher",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/J_KELLEHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb",
          "name": "Jamie Goodrich",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2",
          "name": "John Mackay",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3",
          "uid": "instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31",
          "name": "Rob Streiffer",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": null,
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  },
  {
    "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
    "course_id": "PHILOS 999",
    "title": "INDEPENDENT WORK",
    "credits_min": 2,
    "credits_max": 9,
    "gpa": 4,
    "badges": [
      {
        "id": "rated-teacher",
        "label": "Highly rated instructor",
        "tone": "positive",
        "evidence": "Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.",
        "sources": [
          {
            "label": "James Messina",
            "href": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
          },
          {
            "label": "Larry Shapiro",
            "href": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
          },
          {
            "label": "Steven Nadler",
            "href": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
          },
          {
            "label": "Harry Brighouse",
            "href": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
          },
          {
            "label": "Michael Titelbaum",
            "href": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
          },
          {
            "label": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
            "href": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
          },
          {
            "label": "Peter Vranas",
            "href": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
          }
        ]
      }
    ],
    "description": "PHILOS 999 is an individual mentored study course for graduate students arranged with a faculty member.",
    "discovery": {
      "term": "1272",
      "offered": true,
      "history": {
        "counts": [
          4,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 4,
        "gpa": 4,
        "topShare": 100,
        "firstTerm": "1224",
        "lastTerm": "1224"
      },
      "instructors": [
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6",
          "name": "James Messina",
          "quality": 4.493339601162819,
          "quality_count": 41,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2",
          "name": "Larry Shapiro",
          "quality": 4.445878372979523,
          "quality_count": 81,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6",
          "name": "Steven Nadler",
          "quality": 4.3847532677413925,
          "quality_count": 46,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50",
          "name": "Harry Brighouse",
          "quality": 4.320598844807286,
          "quality_count": 53,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6",
          "name": "Michael Titelbaum",
          "quality": 4.283047643349683,
          "quality_count": 37,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89",
          "name": "Russ Shafer-Landau",
          "quality": 4.281023828762943,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3",
          "name": "Peter Vranas",
          "quality": 4.042690495429611,
          "quality_count": 52,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3",
          "name": "Jesse Steinberg",
          "quality": 3.976963304883769,
          "quality_count": 15,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80",
          "name": "Bruno Whittle",
          "quality": 3.8548428917732975,
          "quality_count": 20,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a",
          "name": "Annina Loets",
          "quality": 3.8252641112403607,
          "quality_count": 13,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7",
          "name": "Annette Zimmermann",
          "quality": 3.788478801917079,
          "quality_count": 17,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_c48098ca387a2eedac71f822",
          "name": "Alexander Meehan",
          "quality": 3.7677486268372764,
          "quality_count": 5,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_MEEHAN"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3",
          "name": "Alexander Roberts",
          "quality": 3.765300540376962,
          "quality_count": 9,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd",
          "name": "Martha Gibson",
          "quality": 3.746528890116297,
          "quality_count": 74,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b",
          "name": "Emily Fletcher",
          "quality": 3.6988132223315873,
          "quality_count": 19,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428",
          "name": "Paula Gottlieb",
          "quality": 3.682845014275147,
          "quality_count": 27,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370",
          "name": "Farid Masrour",
          "quality": 3.501602514585476,
          "quality_count": 26,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b",
          "name": "Aja Watkins",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/AJA_WATKINS"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a",
          "name": "Elliott Sober",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed",
          "name": "Henry Southgate",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_e39149f0f2d81ed7d47ba445",
          "name": "J. Kelleher",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/J_KELLEHER"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb",
          "name": "Jamie Goodrich",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2",
          "name": "John Mackay",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"
        },
        {
          "course_uid": "course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556",
          "uid": "instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31",
          "name": "Rob Streiffer",
          "quality": null,
          "quality_count": null,
          "instructor_url": "/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER"
        }
      ],
      "instructorHistory": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "courseComparison": {
        "counts": [
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0,
          0
        ],
        "count": 0,
        "gpa": null,
        "topShare": null
      },
      "claim": null,
      "reviewFiles": []
    }
  }
]
```

## reviews

### items

```json
[
  {
    "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:17:29.533919+00:00",
    "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
    "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTQyODcxMDIz",
    "source_instructor_id": "rmp:1267337",
    "instructor_name": "Michael Titelbaum",
    "course_label": "Phil-101",
    "course_id": null,
    "course_uid": null,
    "review_date": "2026-04-19 20:20:17 +0000 UTC",
    "comment": "What I would do to take Prof Titelbaum's class again!! He's such an amazing lecturer so I'm writing this review 1 semester later because my philosophy teacher now doesn't even come close. Titelbaum really knows what he's talking about and is so knowledgeable on all aspects of life. ",
    "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1267337",
    "quality_rating": 5,
    "difficulty_rating": 3
  },
  {
    "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:17:29.533919+00:00",
    "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
    "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTQyNDEyOTI4",
    "source_instructor_id": "rmp:1267337",
    "instructor_name": "Michael Titelbaum",
    "course_label": "Phil-101",
    "course_id": null,
    "course_uid": null,
    "review_date": "2025-12-29 15:57:41 +0000 UTC",
    "comment": "His lectures are great if you are interested in philosophy. The TA you have can depend on your grade. My TA was harsh with feedback and harsh on grading attendance which lowered my grade. He will not curve your grade at the end. No extra credit. Pop quizzes based on readings weekly but he dropped the lowest two. Don't take if you aren't interested.",
    "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1267337",
    "quality_rating": 3,
    "difficulty_rating": 3
  },
  {
    "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:17:29.533919+00:00",
    "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
    "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTQyMzE1MTAy",
    "source_instructor_id": "rmp:1267337",
    "instructor_name": "Michael Titelbaum",
    "course_label": "Phil-101",
    "course_id": null,
    "course_uid": null,
    "review_date": "2025-12-17 20:49:36 +0000 UTC",
    "comment": "Loved him, made me love philosophy, 100 percent recommend taking Phil 101 with him he is just too good!",
    "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1267337",
    "quality_rating": 5,
    "difficulty_rating": 3
  },
  {
    "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:17:29.533919+00:00",
    "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
    "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTQwNDIwNTc5",
    "source_instructor_id": "rmp:1267337",
    "instructor_name": "Michael Titelbaum",
    "course_label": "PHILO211",
    "course_id": null,
    "course_uid": null,
    "review_date": "2024-12-23 04:25:30 +0000 UTC",
    "comment": "An amazing professor. This course has many interesting extra credit questions that allow your final grade to exceed 101%. He is mostly careful with gender-nonspecific language until he gets engrossed in lecturing or explaining complex topics. Nevertheless, his lectures are pretty clear&#8212;he well knows what he is teaching.",
    "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1267337",
    "quality_rating": 5,
    "difficulty_rating": 2
  },
  {
    "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:17:29.533919+00:00",
    "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
    "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTQwMjM1Nzk5",
    "source_instructor_id": "rmp:1267337",
    "instructor_name": "Michael Titelbaum",
    "course_label": "PHIL211",
    "course_id": null,
    "course_uid": null,
    "review_date": "2024-12-12 00:11:14 +0000 UTC",
    "comment": "Professor Titelbaum does his best to make difficult material accessible to everyone. He is excellent at explaining logic, and he often adds fun parts into lectures. I got a lot out of this class, but don't expect to be an expert debater after taking intro to logic. That is not what it's about. Highly recommend.",
    "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1267337",
    "quality_rating": 5,
    "difficulty_rating": 4
  },
  {
    "observed_at": "2026-09-07 16:17:29.533919+00:00",
    "run_id": "20260907T155543-ce3781c4",
    "source_review_id": "UmF0aW5nLTM5Nzc4OTc5",
    "source_instructor_id": "rmp:1267337",
    "instructor_name": "Michael Titelbaum",
    "course_label": "LOGIC211",
    "course_id": null,
    "course_uid": null,
    "review_date": "2024-10-01 19:21:26 +0000 UTC",
    "comment": "An amazing professor. He made an otherwise difficult and, in my opinion, boring subject as interesting and engaging as possible. His office hours were incredibly helpful and you could tell he really wanted to see his students succeed. He is the reason I declared a philosophy major!",
    "source_url": "https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1267337",
    "quality_rating": 5,
    "difficulty_rating": 3
  }
]
```

### total

37

### page

1

### courses

| course\_uid                      | course\_id |
| -------------------------------- | ---------- |
| course\_9135c71251486b5b91c37031 | PHILOS 503 |

### matched

true

## social Image

true
