{"schema_version":1,"url":"https://uwcourses.com/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON","title":"Martha Gibson — Courses & Reviews | UW–Madison","dataset":{"revision":"e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349","repository":"twangodev/uwcourses","schema_version":6,"importer_version":"7","projection_id":"52a78527ff09011d88cb04c7d43867d9fbfec2930bf1dd2ec359ebd2844e0b07","observed_at":"2026-09-07T15:55:43.033547+00:00","built_at":"2026-09-10T19:50:42.743001+00:00","courses":8951,"current_instructors":5754,"limited":false,"terms":["1272","1264","1262","1254","1252","1244","1242","1234","1232","1224","1222","1212","1204","1202","1194","1192","1184","1182","1174","1172","1164","1162","1154","1152","1144","1142","1134","1132","1124","1122","1114","1112","1104","1102","1094","1092","1084","1082","1074","1072"],"term":"1272","departments":[{"subject":"AAE","count":90},{"subject":"ABT","count":20},{"subject":"ACCTIS","count":36},{"subject":"ACTSCI","count":14},{"subject":"AFAERO","count":10},{"subject":"AFRICAN","count":87},{"subject":"AFROAMER","count":71},{"subject":"AGROECOL","count":21},{"subject":"AMERIND","count":53},{"subject":"ANAT&PHY","count":7},{"subject":"ANATOMY","count":2},{"subject":"ANESTHES","count":8},{"subject":"ANSCI","count":57},{"subject":"ANTHRO","count":95},{"subject":"ART","count":125},{"subject":"ARTED","count":10},{"subject":"ARTHIST","count":121},{"subject":"ASIALANG","count":129},{"subject":"ASIAN","count":109},{"subject":"ASIANAM","count":28},{"subject":"ASTRON","count":38},{"subject":"ATMOCN","count":69},{"subject":"BIOCHEM","count":51},{"subject":"BIOCORE","count":10},{"subject":"BIOLOGY","count":14},{"subject":"BIOMDSCI","count":18},{"subject":"BME","count":66},{"subject":"BMI","count":41},{"subject":"BMOLCHEM","count":10},{"subject":"BOTANY","count":69},{"subject":"BSE","count":44},{"subject":"C&ESOC","count":73},{"subject":"CBE","count":48},{"subject":"CHEM","count":101},{"subject":"CHICLA","count":52},{"subject":"CIVENGR","count":133},{"subject":"CLASSICS","count":47},{"subject":"CNP","count":10},{"subject":"CNSRSCI","count":50},{"subject":"COMARTS","count":137},{"subject":"COMPBIO","count":15},{"subject":"COMPLIT","count":11},{"subject":"COMPSCI","count":138},{"subject":"COUNPSY","count":78},{"subject":"CRB","count":19},{"subject":"CS&D","count":71},{"subject":"CSCS","count":40},{"subject":"CURRIC","count":193},{"subject":"DANCE","count":93},{"subject":"DERM","count":8},{"subject":"DS","count":88},{"subject":"DYSCI","count":35},{"subject":"ECE","count":155},{"subject":"ECON","count":145},{"subject":"EDPOL","count":114},{"subject":"EDPSYCH","count":97},{"subject":"ELPA","count":70},{"subject":"EMA","count":53},{"subject":"EMERMED","count":17},{"subject":"ENGL","count":206},{"subject":"ENTOM","count":40},{"subject":"ENVIRST","count":148},{"subject":"EP","count":15},{"subject":"EPD","count":67},{"subject":"ESL","count":16},{"subject":"F&WECOL","count":60},{"subject":"FAMMED","count":22},{"subject":"FINANCE","count":50},{"subject":"FOLKLORE","count":40},{"subject":"FOODSCI","count":43},{"subject":"FRENCH","count":63},{"subject":"GEN&WS","count":145},{"subject":"GENBUS","count":72},{"subject":"GENECSLR","count":17},{"subject":"GENETICS","count":60},{"subject":"GEOG","count":113},{"subject":"GEOSCI","count":83},{"subject":"GERMAN","count":82},{"subject":"GLE","count":48},{"subject":"GNS","count":38},{"subject":"GREEK","count":27},{"subject":"HDFS","count":41},{"subject":"HEBR-BIB","count":13},{"subject":"HEBR-MOD","count":10},{"subject":"HISTORY","count":233},{"subject":"HISTSCI","count":56},{"subject":"HONCOL","count":13},{"subject":"ILS","count":43},{"subject":"INFOSYS","count":9},{"subject":"INTEGART","count":7},{"subject":"INTEGSCI","count":22},{"subject":"INTER-AG","count":18},{"subject":"INTER-HE","count":11},{"subject":"INTER-LS","count":22},{"subject":"INTEREGR","count":16},{"subject":"INTLBUS","count":21},{"subject":"INTLST","count":50},{"subject":"ISYE","count":83},{"subject":"ITALIAN","count":53},{"subject":"JEWISH","count":56},{"subject":"JOURN","count":88},{"subject":"KINES","count":128},{"subject":"LACIS","count":26},{"subject":"LANDARC","count":61},{"subject":"LATIN","count":24},{"subject":"LAW","count":120},{"subject":"LEGALST","count":48},{"subject":"LINGUIS","count":35},{"subject":"LIS","count":89},{"subject":"LITTRANS","count":78},{"subject":"LSC","count":52},{"subject":"M&ENVTOX","count":7},{"subject":"MARKETNG","count":62},{"subject":"MATH","count":153},{"subject":"MDGENET","count":8},{"subject":"ME","count":130},{"subject":"MEDHIST","count":43},{"subject":"MEDICINE","count":60},{"subject":"MEDIEVAL","count":32},{"subject":"MEDPHYS","count":39},{"subject":"MEDSC-M","count":29},{"subject":"MEDSC-V","count":41},{"subject":"MHR","count":68},{"subject":"MICROBIO","count":45},{"subject":"MILSCI","count":16},{"subject":"MM&I","count":22},{"subject":"MOLBIOL","count":6},{"subject":"MS&E","count":59},{"subject":"MUSIC","count":165},{"subject":"MUSPERF","count":126},{"subject":"NAVSCI","count":20},{"subject":"NE","count":44},{"subject":"NEURODPT","count":11},{"subject":"NEUROL","count":7},{"subject":"NEURSURG","count":4},{"subject":"NTP","count":11},{"subject":"NURSING","count":111},{"subject":"NUTRSCI","count":65},{"subject":"OBS&GYN","count":18},{"subject":"OCCTHER","count":39},{"subject":"ONCOLOGY","count":14},{"subject":"OPHTHALM","count":5},{"subject":"OTM","count":43},{"subject":"PATH","count":34},{"subject":"PATH-BIO","count":29},{"subject":"PEDIAT","count":26},{"subject":"PHARMACY","count":31},{"subject":"PHILOS","count":77},{"subject":"PHMCOL-M","count":11},{"subject":"PHMPRAC","count":45},{"subject":"PHMSCI","count":60},{"subject":"PHYASST","count":37},{"subject":"PHYSICS","count":88},{"subject":"PHYSIOL","count":3},{"subject":"PHYTHER","count":37},{"subject":"PLANTSCI","count":52},{"subject":"PLPATH","count":35},{"subject":"POLISCI","count":192},{"subject":"POPHLTH","count":58},{"subject":"PORTUG","count":33},{"subject":"PSYCH","count":101},{"subject":"PSYCHIAT","count":22},{"subject":"PUBAFFR","count":54},{"subject":"PUBLHLTH","count":23},{"subject":"RADIOL","count":11},{"subject":"REALEST","count":41},{"subject":"RELIGST","count":90},{"subject":"RHABMED","count":9},{"subject":"RMI","count":24},{"subject":"RP&SE","count":102},{"subject":"S&APHM","count":17},{"subject":"SCANDST","count":73},{"subject":"SLAVIC","count":89},{"subject":"SOC","count":149},{"subject":"SOCWORK","count":87},{"subject":"SOILSCI","count":46},{"subject":"SPANISH","count":83},{"subject":"SRMED","count":21},{"subject":"STAT","count":94},{"subject":"STDYABRD","count":52},{"subject":"STS","count":8},{"subject":"SURGERY","count":25},{"subject":"SURGSCI","count":33},{"subject":"THEATRE","count":91},{"subject":"URBRPL","count":60},{"subject":"UROLOGY","count":5},{"subject":"ZOOLOGY","count":89}],"deployed_at":null},"data":{"instructor":{"instructor_uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","source":"enrollment","source_instructor_id":"migibson","identity_basis":"netid","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"Martha Gibson","email":"MIGIBSON@WISC.EDU","first_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","ratings":{"review_count":74,"quality":3.77,"difficulty":3.09,"quality_count":74,"difficulty_count":74,"profile_id":"rmp:18444","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","match_basis":"exact_name","observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:20:22.154889+00:00","courses":{"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7":{"review_count":12,"quality":3.92,"difficulty":3.08,"quality_count":12,"difficulty_count":12},"course_902ab056721ed2c6be9738ad":{"review_count":1,"quality":5,"difficulty":4,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1}},"bayesian_quality":3.746528890116297,"prior_mean":3.6596857835465957,"prior_weight":20},"current":true,"courses":[{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","course_id":"PHILOS 990","title":"RESEARCH AND THESIS","credits_min":2,"credits_max":9,"gpa":null},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","course_id":"PHILOS 699","title":"DIRECTED STUDY","credits_min":2,"credits_max":3,"gpa":null},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","course_id":"PHILOS 999","title":"INDEPENDENT WORK","credits_min":2,"credits_max":9,"gpa":4},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","course_id":"PHILOS 682","title":"SENIOR HONORS THESIS","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"gpa":4},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","course_id":"PHILOS 681","title":"SENIOR HONORS THESIS","credits_min":1,"credits_max":3,"gpa":null},{"course_uid":"course_902ab056721ed2c6be9738ad","course_id":"PHILOS 916","title":"SEMINAR-PHILOSOPHY OF LANGUAGE","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"gpa":3.757},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","course_id":"PHILOS 599","title":"DIRECTED STUDY","credits_min":1,"credits_max":3,"gpa":4},{"course_uid":"course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4","course_id":"PHILOS 701","title":"READING SEMINAR","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"gpa":4}],"revision":"e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349","instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"},"history":[{"term":"1272","course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","course_id":"PHILOS 599","title":"DIRECTED STUDY"},{"term":"1272","course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","course_id":"PHILOS 681","title":"SENIOR HONORS THESIS"},{"term":"1272","course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","course_id":"PHILOS 682","title":"SENIOR HONORS THESIS"},{"term":"1272","course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","course_id":"PHILOS 699","title":"DIRECTED STUDY"},{"term":"1272","course_uid":"course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4","course_id":"PHILOS 701","title":"READING SEMINAR"},{"term":"1272","course_uid":"course_902ab056721ed2c6be9738ad","course_id":"PHILOS 916","title":"SEMINAR-PHILOSOPHY OF LANGUAGE"},{"term":"1272","course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","course_id":"PHILOS 990","title":"RESEARCH AND THESIS"},{"term":"1272","course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","course_id":"PHILOS 999","title":"INDEPENDENT WORK"}],"timeline":[{"term":"1272","courses":8}],"term":"1272","courses":[{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","course_id":"PHILOS 599","title":"DIRECTED STUDY","credits_min":1,"credits_max":3,"gpa":4,"badges":[{"id":"rated-teacher","label":"Highly rated instructor","tone":"positive","evidence":"Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.","sources":[{"label":"James Messina","href":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"label":"Larry Shapiro","href":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"label":"Steven Nadler","href":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"label":"Harry Brighouse","href":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"label":"Michael Titelbaum","href":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"label":"Russ Shafer-Landau","href":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"label":"Peter Vranas","href":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"}]}],"description":"PHILOS 599 is a directed study course allowing students to pursue independent research or study topics arranged with a faculty member.","discovery":{"term":"1272","offered":true,"history":{"counts":[9,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":9,"gpa":4,"topShare":100,"firstTerm":"1224","lastTerm":"1264"},"instructors":[{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6","name":"James Messina","quality":4.493339601162819,"quality_count":41,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2","name":"Larry Shapiro","quality":4.445878372979523,"quality_count":81,"instructor_url":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6","name":"Steven Nadler","quality":4.3847532677413925,"quality_count":46,"instructor_url":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50","name":"Harry Brighouse","quality":4.320598844807286,"quality_count":53,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6","name":"Michael Titelbaum","quality":4.283047643349683,"quality_count":37,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89","name":"Russ Shafer-Landau","quality":4.281023828762943,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3","name":"Peter Vranas","quality":4.042690495429611,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3","name":"Jesse Steinberg","quality":3.976963304883769,"quality_count":15,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80","name":"Bruno Whittle","quality":3.8548428917732975,"quality_count":20,"instructor_url":"/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a","name":"Annina Loets","quality":3.8252641112403607,"quality_count":13,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","name":"Martha Gibson","quality":3.746528890116297,"quality_count":74,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_e8b96304e9a1ede9e5f5bdfd","name":"Sam Roberts","quality":3.7235102700443767,"quality_count":1,"instructor_url":"/instructors/SAM_ROBERTS"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b","name":"Emily Fletcher","quality":3.6988132223315873,"quality_count":19,"instructor_url":"/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428","name":"Paula Gottlieb","quality":3.682845014275147,"quality_count":27,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","name":"Farid Masrour","quality":3.501602514585476,"quality_count":26,"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a","name":"Elliott Sober","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed","name":"Henry Southgate","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"},{"course_uid":"course_97698a6ee4d9ce06a0f4a474","uid":"instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2","name":"John Mackay","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"}],"instructorHistory":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"courseComparison":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"claim":null,"reviewFiles":[]}},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","course_id":"PHILOS 681","title":"SENIOR HONORS THESIS","credits_min":1,"credits_max":3,"gpa":null,"badges":[{"id":"rated-teacher","label":"Highly rated instructor","tone":"positive","evidence":"Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.","sources":[{"label":"James Messina","href":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"label":"Larry Shapiro","href":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"label":"Steven Nadler","href":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"label":"Harry Brighouse","href":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"label":"Michael Titelbaum","href":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"label":"Russ Shafer-Landau","href":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"label":"Peter Vranas","href":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"}]}],"description":"PHILOS 681 is a mentored study course for senior Philosophy majors to complete honors theses.","discovery":{"term":"1272","offered":true,"history":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"instructors":[{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6","name":"James Messina","quality":4.493339601162819,"quality_count":41,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2","name":"Larry Shapiro","quality":4.445878372979523,"quality_count":81,"instructor_url":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6","name":"Steven Nadler","quality":4.3847532677413925,"quality_count":46,"instructor_url":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50","name":"Harry Brighouse","quality":4.320598844807286,"quality_count":53,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6","name":"Michael Titelbaum","quality":4.283047643349683,"quality_count":37,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89","name":"Russ Shafer-Landau","quality":4.281023828762943,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3","name":"Peter Vranas","quality":4.042690495429611,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3","name":"Jesse Steinberg","quality":3.976963304883769,"quality_count":15,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80","name":"Bruno Whittle","quality":3.8548428917732975,"quality_count":20,"instructor_url":"/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a","name":"Annina Loets","quality":3.8252641112403607,"quality_count":13,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7","name":"Annette Zimmermann","quality":3.788478801917079,"quality_count":17,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3","name":"Alexander Roberts","quality":3.765300540376962,"quality_count":9,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","name":"Martha Gibson","quality":3.746528890116297,"quality_count":74,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b","name":"Emily Fletcher","quality":3.6988132223315873,"quality_count":19,"instructor_url":"/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428","name":"Paula Gottlieb","quality":3.682845014275147,"quality_count":27,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","name":"Farid Masrour","quality":3.501602514585476,"quality_count":26,"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b","name":"Aja Watkins","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/AJA_WATKINS"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_0f03a205f447f6b55f01251f","name":"Elizabeth Brake","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ELIZABETH_BRAKE"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a","name":"Elliott Sober","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed","name":"Henry Southgate","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb","name":"Jamie Goodrich","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2","name":"John Mackay","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"},{"course_uid":"course_5e5a87f73ce273d67355c810","uid":"instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31","name":"Rob Streiffer","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER"}],"instructorHistory":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"courseComparison":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"claim":null,"reviewFiles":[]}},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","course_id":"PHILOS 682","title":"SENIOR HONORS THESIS","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"gpa":4,"badges":[{"id":"rated-teacher","label":"Highly rated instructor","tone":"positive","evidence":"Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.","sources":[{"label":"James Messina","href":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"label":"Larry Shapiro","href":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"label":"Steven Nadler","href":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"label":"Harry Brighouse","href":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"label":"Michael Titelbaum","href":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"label":"Russ Shafer-Landau","href":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"label":"Peter Vranas","href":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"}]}],"description":"PHILOS 682 is a mentored study course for seniors completing honors theses in the Philosophy major.","discovery":{"term":"1272","offered":true,"history":{"counts":[4,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":4,"gpa":4,"topShare":100,"firstTerm":"1224","lastTerm":"1224"},"instructors":[{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6","name":"James Messina","quality":4.493339601162819,"quality_count":41,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2","name":"Larry Shapiro","quality":4.445878372979523,"quality_count":81,"instructor_url":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6","name":"Steven Nadler","quality":4.3847532677413925,"quality_count":46,"instructor_url":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50","name":"Harry Brighouse","quality":4.320598844807286,"quality_count":53,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6","name":"Michael Titelbaum","quality":4.283047643349683,"quality_count":37,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89","name":"Russ Shafer-Landau","quality":4.281023828762943,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3","name":"Peter Vranas","quality":4.042690495429611,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3","name":"Jesse Steinberg","quality":3.976963304883769,"quality_count":15,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80","name":"Bruno Whittle","quality":3.8548428917732975,"quality_count":20,"instructor_url":"/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7","name":"Annette Zimmermann","quality":3.788478801917079,"quality_count":17,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3","name":"Alexander Roberts","quality":3.765300540376962,"quality_count":9,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","name":"Martha Gibson","quality":3.746528890116297,"quality_count":74,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b","name":"Emily Fletcher","quality":3.6988132223315873,"quality_count":19,"instructor_url":"/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428","name":"Paula Gottlieb","quality":3.682845014275147,"quality_count":27,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","name":"Farid Masrour","quality":3.501602514585476,"quality_count":26,"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a","name":"Elliott Sober","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed","name":"Henry Southgate","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb","name":"Jamie Goodrich","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2","name":"John Mackay","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"},{"course_uid":"course_2c81e4f4233fa57ad8c56280","uid":"instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31","name":"Rob Streiffer","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER"}],"instructorHistory":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"courseComparison":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"claim":null,"reviewFiles":[]}},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","course_id":"PHILOS 699","title":"DIRECTED STUDY","credits_min":2,"credits_max":3,"gpa":null,"badges":[{"id":"rated-teacher","label":"Highly rated instructor","tone":"positive","evidence":"Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.","sources":[{"label":"James Messina","href":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"label":"Larry Shapiro","href":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"label":"Steven Nadler","href":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"label":"Harry Brighouse","href":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"label":"Michael Titelbaum","href":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"label":"Russ Shafer-Landau","href":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"label":"Peter Vranas","href":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"}]}],"description":"PHILOS 699 is a directed study course allowing independent research arranged with a faculty member.","discovery":{"term":"1272","offered":true,"history":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"instructors":[{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6","name":"James Messina","quality":4.493339601162819,"quality_count":41,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2","name":"Larry Shapiro","quality":4.445878372979523,"quality_count":81,"instructor_url":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6","name":"Steven Nadler","quality":4.3847532677413925,"quality_count":46,"instructor_url":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50","name":"Harry Brighouse","quality":4.320598844807286,"quality_count":53,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6","name":"Michael Titelbaum","quality":4.283047643349683,"quality_count":37,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89","name":"Russ Shafer-Landau","quality":4.281023828762943,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3","name":"Peter Vranas","quality":4.042690495429611,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3","name":"Jesse Steinberg","quality":3.976963304883769,"quality_count":15,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80","name":"Bruno Whittle","quality":3.8548428917732975,"quality_count":20,"instructor_url":"/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","name":"Martha Gibson","quality":3.746528890116297,"quality_count":74,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b","name":"Emily Fletcher","quality":3.6988132223315873,"quality_count":19,"instructor_url":"/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428","name":"Paula Gottlieb","quality":3.682845014275147,"quality_count":27,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","name":"Farid Masrour","quality":3.501602514585476,"quality_count":26,"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a","name":"Elliott Sober","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed","name":"Henry Southgate","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"},{"course_uid":"course_26e8125a75c5989423cc9076","uid":"instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2","name":"John Mackay","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"}],"instructorHistory":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"courseComparison":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"claim":null,"reviewFiles":[]}},{"course_uid":"course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4","course_id":"PHILOS 701","title":"READING SEMINAR","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"gpa":4,"badges":[{"id":"rated-teacher","label":"Highly rated instructor","tone":"positive","evidence":"Fall 2026: Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.","sources":[{"label":"Michael Titelbaum","href":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"}]}],"description":"PHILOS 701 is a reading seminar that examines select topics in philosophy.","discovery":{"term":"1272","offered":true,"history":{"counts":[11,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":11,"gpa":4,"topShare":100,"firstTerm":"1224","lastTerm":"1232"},"instructors":[{"course_uid":"course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4","uid":"instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6","name":"Michael Titelbaum","quality":4.283047643349683,"quality_count":37,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"course_uid":"course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4","uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","name":"Martha Gibson","quality":3.746528890116297,"quality_count":74,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"},{"course_uid":"course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4","uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","name":"Farid Masrour","quality":3.501602514585476,"quality_count":26,"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"},{"course_uid":"course_a7560fb2916e84ab1f0cf0e4","uid":"instructor_e36586ff1ce5d9f82bf1ddc9","name":"Sophia Dandelet","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/SOPHIA_DANDELET"}],"instructorHistory":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"courseComparison":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"claim":null,"reviewFiles":[]}},{"course_uid":"course_902ab056721ed2c6be9738ad","course_id":"PHILOS 916","title":"SEMINAR-PHILOSOPHY OF LANGUAGE","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"gpa":3.757,"badges":[{"id":"lecture-size","label":"Small lectures","tone":"neutral","evidence":"Fall 2026: median 8 enrolled students across 1 recorded lecture section. Small means 30 or fewer; large means 100 or more. Enrollment at scan time, not capacity or typical historical attendance.","sources":[{"label":"Sections and enrollment","href":"/courses/PHILOS_916#schedule"}]}],"description":"A graduate seminar focused on the philosophy of language.","discovery":{"term":"1272","offered":true,"history":{"counts":[1,1,0,0,0,0,0],"count":2,"gpa":3.75,"topShare":100,"firstTerm":"1264","lastTerm":"1264"},"instructors":[{"course_uid":"course_902ab056721ed2c6be9738ad","uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","name":"Martha Gibson","quality":3.746528890116297,"quality_count":74,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"}],"instructorHistory":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"courseComparison":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"claim":{"citations":[{"instructor_name":"Martha Gibson","review_date":"2003-02-01 01:56:18 +0000 UTC","review_id":"7990860e86d0f5fba6f3d036","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_instructor_id":"rmp:18444","source_review_id":"UmF0aW5nLTUzMjUxMw==","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","type":"review"}],"text":"Martha Gibson is described as one of the best teachers with high standards, yet she actively helps students meet those expectations. This review highlights her effectiveness in supporting student success despite rigorous requirements."},"reviewFiles":["/data/e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349/reviews/course_902ab056721ed2c6be9738ad-0.json"]}},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","course_id":"PHILOS 990","title":"RESEARCH AND THESIS","credits_min":2,"credits_max":9,"gpa":null,"badges":[{"id":"rated-teacher","label":"Highly rated instructor","tone":"positive","evidence":"Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.","sources":[{"label":"James Messina","href":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"label":"Larry Shapiro","href":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"label":"Steven Nadler","href":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"label":"Harry Brighouse","href":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"label":"Michael Titelbaum","href":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"label":"Russ Shafer-Landau","href":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"label":"Peter Vranas","href":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"}]}],"description":"PHILOS 990 is a graduate research and thesis course involving individual mentored study arranged with a faculty member.","discovery":{"term":"1272","offered":true,"history":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"instructors":[{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6","name":"James Messina","quality":4.493339601162819,"quality_count":41,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2","name":"Larry Shapiro","quality":4.445878372979523,"quality_count":81,"instructor_url":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6","name":"Steven Nadler","quality":4.3847532677413925,"quality_count":46,"instructor_url":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50","name":"Harry Brighouse","quality":4.320598844807286,"quality_count":53,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6","name":"Michael Titelbaum","quality":4.283047643349683,"quality_count":37,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89","name":"Russ Shafer-Landau","quality":4.281023828762943,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3","name":"Peter Vranas","quality":4.042690495429611,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3","name":"Jesse Steinberg","quality":3.976963304883769,"quality_count":15,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80","name":"Bruno Whittle","quality":3.8548428917732975,"quality_count":20,"instructor_url":"/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a","name":"Annina Loets","quality":3.8252641112403607,"quality_count":13,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7","name":"Annette Zimmermann","quality":3.788478801917079,"quality_count":17,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_c48098ca387a2eedac71f822","name":"Alexander Meehan","quality":3.7677486268372764,"quality_count":5,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ALEXANDER_MEEHAN"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3","name":"Alexander Roberts","quality":3.765300540376962,"quality_count":9,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","name":"Martha Gibson","quality":3.746528890116297,"quality_count":74,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b","name":"Emily Fletcher","quality":3.6988132223315873,"quality_count":19,"instructor_url":"/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428","name":"Paula Gottlieb","quality":3.682845014275147,"quality_count":27,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","name":"Farid Masrour","quality":3.501602514585476,"quality_count":26,"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b","name":"Aja Watkins","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/AJA_WATKINS"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_0f03a205f447f6b55f01251f","name":"Elizabeth Brake","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ELIZABETH_BRAKE"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a","name":"Elliott Sober","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed","name":"Henry Southgate","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_e39149f0f2d81ed7d47ba445","name":"J. Kelleher","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/J_KELLEHER"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb","name":"Jamie Goodrich","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2","name":"John Mackay","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"},{"course_uid":"course_2669442b26c0a7866da3daa3","uid":"instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31","name":"Rob Streiffer","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER"}],"instructorHistory":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"courseComparison":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"claim":null,"reviewFiles":[]}},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","course_id":"PHILOS 999","title":"INDEPENDENT WORK","credits_min":2,"credits_max":9,"gpa":4,"badges":[{"id":"rated-teacher","label":"Highly rated instructor","tone":"positive","evidence":"Fall 2026: James Messina (4.49/5 adjusted; 41 ratings); Larry Shapiro (4.45/5 adjusted; 81 ratings); Steven Nadler (4.38/5 adjusted; 46 ratings); Harry Brighouse (4.32/5 adjusted; 53 ratings); Michael Titelbaum (4.28/5 adjusted; 37 ratings); Russ Shafer-Landau (4.28/5 adjusted; 52 ratings); Peter Vranas (4.04/5 adjusted; 52 ratings). At least one assigned instructor qualifies. This describes instructor reviews across courses, not a course rating.","sources":[{"label":"James Messina","href":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"label":"Larry Shapiro","href":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"label":"Steven Nadler","href":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"label":"Harry Brighouse","href":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"label":"Michael Titelbaum","href":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"label":"Russ Shafer-Landau","href":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"label":"Peter Vranas","href":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"}]}],"description":"PHILOS 999 is an individual mentored study course for graduate students arranged with a faculty member.","discovery":{"term":"1272","offered":true,"history":{"counts":[4,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":4,"gpa":4,"topShare":100,"firstTerm":"1224","lastTerm":"1224"},"instructors":[{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_16f8fe4b6f131823342323d6","name":"James Messina","quality":4.493339601162819,"quality_count":41,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMES_MESSINA"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_d02d1499d7504d65076acea2","name":"Larry Shapiro","quality":4.445878372979523,"quality_count":81,"instructor_url":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_6e6bd14a0a58851d87a1b0b6","name":"Steven Nadler","quality":4.3847532677413925,"quality_count":46,"instructor_url":"/instructors/STEVEN_NADLER"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_62a291c3789661c450c3cf50","name":"Harry Brighouse","quality":4.320598844807286,"quality_count":53,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HARRY_BRIGHOUSE"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_64b1a465fafbbb0acb1a41f6","name":"Michael Titelbaum","quality":4.283047643349683,"quality_count":37,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MICHAEL_TITELBAUM"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_010858ea8245015bb743ad89","name":"Russ Shafer-Landau","quality":4.281023828762943,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/RUSS_SHAFER-LANDAU"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_77d9925c5b5538a873ee99a3","name":"Peter Vranas","quality":4.042690495429611,"quality_count":52,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PETER_VRANAS"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_01c3a0c97a405e33b7caada3","name":"Jesse Steinberg","quality":3.976963304883769,"quality_count":15,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JESSE_STEINBERG"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_cd0723ef8962104e931c2b80","name":"Bruno Whittle","quality":3.8548428917732975,"quality_count":20,"instructor_url":"/instructors/BRUNO_WHITTLE"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_2888f6829e692d97678f799a","name":"Annina Loets","quality":3.8252641112403607,"quality_count":13,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ANNINA_LOETS"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_7bbfb2e3c3ecdd1e6a9fa3e7","name":"Annette Zimmermann","quality":3.788478801917079,"quality_count":17,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ANNETTE_ZIMMERMANN"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_c48098ca387a2eedac71f822","name":"Alexander Meehan","quality":3.7677486268372764,"quality_count":5,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ALEXANDER_MEEHAN"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_08807cd2ac44bfb0e40a41b3","name":"Alexander Roberts","quality":3.765300540376962,"quality_count":9,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ALEXANDER_ROBERTS"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_481e7d027d216e74340d06bd","name":"Martha Gibson","quality":3.746528890116297,"quality_count":74,"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_3f22d0d457a549aedee5725b","name":"Emily Fletcher","quality":3.6988132223315873,"quality_count":19,"instructor_url":"/instructors/EMILY_FLETCHER"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_2e27d38012ede39bdf36c428","name":"Paula Gottlieb","quality":3.682845014275147,"quality_count":27,"instructor_url":"/instructors/PAULA_GOTTLIEB"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","name":"Farid Masrour","quality":3.501602514585476,"quality_count":26,"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_0a97473a2b67c95f5f7cc68b","name":"Aja Watkins","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/AJA_WATKINS"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_b1d8d6f6e60e1d7c8484b25a","name":"Elliott Sober","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ELLIOTT_SOBER"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_513edfe415d65420ea8279ed","name":"Henry Southgate","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/HENRY_SOUTHGATE"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_e39149f0f2d81ed7d47ba445","name":"J. Kelleher","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/J_KELLEHER"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_3de0e143212e4712cccb7bcb","name":"Jamie Goodrich","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JAMIE_GOODRICH"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_d7cdc1292e3879c3eecb87b2","name":"John Mackay","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/JOHN_MACKAY"},{"course_uid":"course_289e73f4cd1b9bba4f865556","uid":"instructor_78142d2b6f74e24454150c31","name":"Rob Streiffer","quality":null,"quality_count":null,"instructor_url":"/instructors/ROB_STREIFFER"}],"instructorHistory":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"courseComparison":{"counts":[0,0,0,0,0,0,0],"count":0,"gpa":null,"topShare":null},"claim":null,"reviewFiles":[]}}],"reviews":{"items":[{"observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:20:22.154889+00:00","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_review_id":"UmF0aW5nLTQyNTI1Mjcy","source_instructor_id":"rmp:18444","instructor_name":"Martha Gibson","course_label":"PHILOS101","course_id":"PHILOS 101","course_uid":"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7","review_date":"2026-01-20 20:53:35 +0000 UTC","comment":"very tough grader and exams are quite difficult. Lecture attendance is mandatory as all the content is delivered there and no recordings are available. Her handwriting is quite bad, so make sure to follow along closely. She does however really care about her studnets and is eager to help you succeed.","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","quality_rating":4,"difficulty_rating":3},{"observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:20:22.154889+00:00","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_review_id":"UmF0aW5nLTQyMDEwNTMw","source_instructor_id":"rmp:18444","instructor_name":"Martha Gibson","course_label":"PHIL530","course_id":null,"course_uid":null,"review_date":"2025-12-03 15:07:53 +0000 UTC","comment":"Martha is an amazing upper-level philosophy professor. She can be a little hard to get used to (her teaching, grading, and communication style), but she really respects her students, treats us as people, is very flexible, understanding, and genuinely wants us to succeed. Once you are used to her exam style, you will easily be able to succeed.","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","quality_rating":5,"difficulty_rating":4},{"observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:20:22.154889+00:00","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_review_id":"UmF0aW5nLTQxNjc3NzU3","source_instructor_id":"rmp:18444","instructor_name":"Martha Gibson","course_label":"PHILO101","course_id":null,"course_uid":null,"review_date":"2025-10-01 03:29:51 +0000 UTC","comment":"Martha is kind, but her handwriting makes lectures very difficult to follow if you do not hang onto every word. Most of what you will discuss is regurgitated from readings. Lectures are very redundant, but take-home tests require extensive comprehension that sometimes goes beyond the level of class conversation.","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","quality_rating":3,"difficulty_rating":3},{"observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:20:22.154889+00:00","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_review_id":"UmF0aW5nLTQxNjIzMzA1","source_instructor_id":"rmp:18444","instructor_name":"Martha Gibson","course_label":"432","course_id":null,"course_uid":null,"review_date":"2025-09-04 22:59:03 +0000 UTC","comment":"Modern History with Gibson was hard. You can't BS the exams, she wants premise-conclusion arguments in paragraph form and will ding points both for logical mistakes and bad writing. But an A is doable if you attend most/all the lectures and do the readings. Also there's like zero discussion, but you learn more than in lower level debate-y classes.","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","quality_rating":4,"difficulty_rating":5},{"observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:20:22.154889+00:00","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_review_id":"UmF0aW5nLTQxMTUwMDYy","source_instructor_id":"rmp:18444","instructor_name":"Martha Gibson","course_label":"432","course_id":null,"course_uid":null,"review_date":"2025-05-04 05:24:53 +0000 UTC","comment":"Martha and her TA do not have a clear standard of grading. They say the standard answer is composed of 7-8 sentences, but the sample they offered is 1.5 page long. ","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","quality_rating":1,"difficulty_rating":5},{"observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:20:22.154889+00:00","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_review_id":"UmF0aW5nLTQxMTI1OTQ5","source_instructor_id":"rmp:18444","instructor_name":"Martha Gibson","course_label":"432","course_id":null,"course_uid":null,"review_date":"2025-05-01 22:30:10 +0000 UTC","comment":"Martha is very sweet and caring. Difficult course, but you learn a lot and improve your writing. Not an easy A, but a good class if you invest in the course and the material. Exams are asynchronous and you have 1-2 weeks to complete them. Allows you to build better comprehension of the mateiral without the stress of in class exams","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","quality_rating":5,"difficulty_rating":4}],"total":74,"page":1,"courses":[{"course_uid":"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7","course_id":"PHILOS 101"},{"course_uid":"course_902ab056721ed2c6be9738ad","course_id":"PHILOS 916"}],"matched":true},"socialImage":true}}