[{"run_id":"20261014T203208-0851c9a1","observed_at":"2026-10-14 17:50:09.728220+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"e722b813d06209290bcbe42f718f76544e37be4807dcd7f2ab9c3738c2fca867","record_version_id":"ff88ca7c91785e77f66b43ee1f2de9e4c6c948473f7b6a1cceab986e9e4e9e56","job_id":"enrich-49752a259f17fab0f49665b3","output_id":"08e2fe741b257a5ddb40e4cb434f5491d23f9f947763090eb022ba57357a1fb2","section":"requirements","status":"needs_review","value_json":"{\"nodes\":[{\"children\":[\"r1_any\",\"r2_cond\"],\"condition\":null,\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"(ART 107,176,318,429, or529) or (declared in an Art MFA or Design + Innovation MS)\",\"id\":\"root\",\"kind\":\"any\"},{\"children\":[\"c_art107\",\"c_art176\",\"c_art318\",\"c_art429\",\"c_art529\"],\"condition\":null,\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"(ART 107,176,318,429, or529)\",\"id\":\"r1_any\",\"kind\":\"any\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":107,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"ART 107\",\"id\":\"c_art107\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":176,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"176\",\"id\":\"c_art176\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":318,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"318\",\"id\":\"c_art318\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":429,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"429\",\"id\":\"c_art429\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":529,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"or529\",\"id\":\"c_art529\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":\"declared in an Art MFA or Design + Innovation MS\",\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"declared in an Art MFA or Design + Innovation MS\",\"id\":\"r2_cond\",\"kind\":\"condition\"}],\"notes\":[],\"root\":\"root\",\"status\":\"parsed\"}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B","model_revision":"1d4bf0f2ff6012fd82039f2fa52739d0dd7c60c0","selected_for_release":true},{"run_id":"20261014T203208-0851c9a1","observed_at":"2026-10-14 17:50:09.728220+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"e722b813d06209290bcbe42f718f76544e37be4807dcd7f2ab9c3738c2fca867","record_version_id":"ff88ca7c91785e77f66b43ee1f2de9e4c6c948473f7b6a1cceab986e9e4e9e56","job_id":"enrich-49752a259f17fab0f49665b3","output_id":"08e2fe741b257a5ddb40e4cb434f5491d23f9f947763090eb022ba57357a1fb2","section":"search_profile","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"activity_tags\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Learn a range of 2D animation techniques and how to create and manipulate images and video using software tools to create narrative or fine art videos.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"label\":\"programming\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":1,\"quote\":\"Demonstrate pre-production techniques including mind mapping, story boarding, screenplays, and animatics.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"label\":\"writing\"}],\"assumed_background\":[],\"search_phrases\":[\"2D digital animation studio\",\"narrative or fine art video production\",\"animation principles and pre-production\",\"rotoscoped hand animation techniques\",\"digital imaging for artists\",\"storyboarding and animatics in animation\"],\"skills_taught\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":0,\"quote\":\"Understand the 12 principles of animation.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Understanding the 12 principles of animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":1,\"quote\":\"Demonstrate pre-production techniques including mind mapping, story boarding, screenplays, and animatics.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Applying pre-production techniques like mind mapping, storyboarding, and animatics\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":3,\"quote\":\"Understand the techniques involved in the following animation types, 2D digital limited animation, 2D digital full animation, 2.5D digital full animation, and rotoscoped hand animation.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Executing various 2D and 2.5D digital animation styles including rotoscopy\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":6,\"quote\":\"Incorporate digital imaging techniques into research.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Integrating digital imaging methods into artistic research\"}],\"summary\":{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"title\",\"quote\":\"2D ANIMATION STUDIO\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Focused on 2D digital animation. Learn a range of 2D animation techniques and how to create and manipulate images and video using software tools to create narrative or fine art videos.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"A studio course focused on 2D digital animation, teaching students to use software tools to create narrative or fine art videos while exploring the history and current practice of the field.\"},\"topics\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Explore history and current practice in this emerging field of fine art and the implications of these tools for artists\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"History and contemporary practice of digital animation as fine art\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":4,\"quote\":\"Understand the elements and principles of design in the context of the moving image.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Design elements and principles applied to moving images\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":5,\"quote\":\"understand contemporary practice in the field, including the use of image manipulation in fine art, design and entertainment.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Image manipulation across fine art, design, and entertainment sectors\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B","model_revision":"1d4bf0f2ff6012fd82039f2fa52739d0dd7c60c0","selected_for_release":true},{"run_id":"20261014T203208-0851c9a1","observed_at":"2026-10-14 17:50:09.728220+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"e722b813d06209290bcbe42f718f76544e37be4807dcd7f2ab9c3738c2fca867","record_version_id":"ff88ca7c91785e77f66b43ee1f2de9e4c6c948473f7b6a1cceab986e9e4e9e56","job_id":"enrich-49752a259f17fab0f49665b3","output_id":"08e2fe741b257a5ddb40e4cb434f5491d23f9f947763090eb022ba57357a1fb2","section":"student_experience","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"status\":\"supported\",\"themes\":[{\"aspect\":\"workload\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"},{\"comment\":\"Stephen was always around to provide feedback. Don't get me wrong- if you don't put work into this course you won't pass. Need to understand the software he teaches you and it's not something you can just wait until the night before and wing it. As long as you give ample time towards your projects, start early and ask for feedback you'll have fun.\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":5,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":2,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2021\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"negative\",\"subject_instructor_id\":null,\"summary\":\"Students report a high workload involving extensive homework and complex tutorials, with one reviewer noting that success requires ample time and early starts rather than last-minute effort.\"},{\"aspect\":\"teaching_clarity\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stephen was always around to provide feedback. Don't get me wrong- if you don't put work into this course you won't pass. Need to understand the software he teaches you and it's not something you can just wait until the night before and wing it. As long as you give ample time towards your projects, start early and ask for feedback you'll have fun.\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":5,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":1,\"review_ids\":[\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2021\",\"review_year_start\":\"2021\"},\"sentiment\":\"positive\",\"subject_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"summary\":\"Cited reviews praise Stephen Hilyard for being available to provide feedback, though they emphasize that students must actively understand the taught software.\"},{\"aspect\":\"organization\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":1,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2016\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"negative\",\"subject_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"summary\":\"One reviewer criticized Stephen Hilyard's lectures as excessively long and suggested that class time could have been better utilized for in-class work.\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B","model_revision":"1d4bf0f2ff6012fd82039f2fa52739d0dd7c60c0","selected_for_release":true},{"run_id":"20261014T203208-0851c9a1","observed_at":"2026-10-14 17:50:09.728220+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"e722b813d06209290bcbe42f718f76544e37be4807dcd7f2ab9c3738c2fca867","record_version_id":"ff88ca7c91785e77f66b43ee1f2de9e4c6c948473f7b6a1cceab986e9e4e9e56","job_id":"enrich-49752a259f17fab0f49665b3","output_id":"08e2fe741b257a5ddb40e4cb434f5491d23f9f947763090eb022ba57357a1fb2","section":"student_summary","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"context_hash\":\"b6cba0b21d5b1186f5e14c880d538fa9302bada08f63c6d5aebf7f945cd7f85b\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"current_instructors\":[],\"difficulty_workload\":[{\"citations\":[{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"}],\"evidence_scope\":\"past_student_reviews\",\"text\":\"The workload included approximately six hours of weekly video tutorials, intense critiques, and long lectures that some students felt reduced time for in-class work.\"}],\"errors\":[],\"historical_context\":[],\"message\":null,\"offered\":true,\"profile_hash\":\"3f5110430805ccdd533c0c072df62d68a8a5f5441c4530bbdb15d419a199a09c\",\"quick_take\":[{\"citations\":[{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"}],\"evidence_scope\":\"past_student_reviews\",\"text\":\"Students found the course engaging when they started projects early and sought feedback, noting that the instructor was available to help.\"},{\"citations\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1254\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1262\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1264\",\"type\":\"grade\"}],\"text\":\"Recent recorded grades — Spring 2025: 3.82 GPA, 95.5% A/AB (n=22 letter grades); Fall 2025: 3.86 GPA, 96.0% A/AB (n=25 letter grades); Spring 2026: 4.00 GPA, 100.0% A/AB (n=24 letter grades).\"}],\"student_experience\":[{\"citations\":[{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"}],\"evidence_scope\":\"past_student_reviews\",\"text\":\"Success required consistent effort and understanding the taught software, as students could not rely on last-minute preparation to pass the course.\"}],\"task_hash\":\"9dea82ef7f2113a5605c1c6030c4f9b19967eb742cc93a78268fb92357d29f5c\",\"teaching_history\":[{\"citations\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1164\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1172\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1174\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1182\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1184\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1222\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1232\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1234\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1242\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20261014T203208-0851c9a1\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1252\",\"type\":\"grade\"}],\"text\":\"STEPHEN HILYARD is recorded teaching in Spring 2016, Fall 2016, Spring 2017, Fall 2017, Spring 2018, Fall 2021, Fall 2022, Spring 2023, Fall 2023, Fall 2024. Recorded history may be incomplete and does not establish a future schedule.\"}],\"term_id\":\"1274\",\"term_name\":\"2027 Sprng\",\"version\":3}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B","model_revision":"1d4bf0f2ff6012fd82039f2fa52739d0dd7c60c0","selected_for_release":true},{"run_id":"20260906T231458-5fdd2fff","observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-5291a20b802b9bbbe22b24cb","output_id":"f0e2a24505372855a8075b002e9de4a6d91a05c234a634da469bb9bc4de601f5","section":"requirements","status":"invalid","value_json":null,"candidate_json":"{\"nodes\":[{\"children\":[\"n0\",\"n1\"],\"condition\":null,\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"(ART 107,176,318,429, or529) or declared in an Art graduate program\",\"id\":\"n0\",\"kind\":\"any\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":107,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"ART 107\",\"id\":\"n1\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":176,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"176\",\"id\":\"n2\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":318,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"318\",\"id\":\"n3\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":429,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"429\",\"id\":\"n4\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":529,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"529\",\"id\":\"n5\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":\"declared in an Art graduate program\",\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"declared in an Art graduate program\",\"id\":\"n6\",\"kind\":\"condition\"}],\"notes\":[],\"root\":\"n0\",\"status\":\"parsed\"}","error":"Node n0 references itself; remove the self-reference.\nCycle reaches node n0; requirement graphs must be trees.\nUnreachable nodes: n2, n3, n4, n5, n6; connect all conditions and exclusions to the root.","model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260906T231458-5fdd2fff","observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-5291a20b802b9bbbe22b24cb","output_id":"f0e2a24505372855a8075b002e9de4a6d91a05c234a634da469bb9bc4de601f5","section":"search_profile","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"assumed_background\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 107\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"An introduction to a range of digital media techniques for artists and designers, including digital imaging, vector graphics, web design and 3D digital modeling.\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 429\",\"field\":\"requirements_text\",\"quote\":\"ART 107or declared in an Art graduate program\"}],\"text\":\"Foundational digital media techniques and imaging tools\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 318\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"An introduction to time-based art forms including video, installation, and visual art performance.\"}],\"text\":\"Time-based art forms such as video and performance\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 429\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Introduction to three-dimensional modeling in the computer, in particular the use of 3D digital models for the creation of images and objects.\"}],\"text\":\"3D digital modeling concepts\"}],\"search_phrases\":[\"digital fine arts studio\",\"digital imaging graduate course\",\"ART 428 digital art\",\"digital painting video editing animation\"],\"skills_taught\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Students will create and manipulate both static and moving imagery\"}],\"text\":\"Creation and manipulation of static and moving imagery\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"implications for digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing/post-production, and narrative or non-narrative 2D animation\"}],\"text\":\"Digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing, and 2D animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"refining conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms as powerful tools for generating and communicating images and ideas\"}],\"text\":\"Conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms\"}],\"summary\":{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Explore current and historical practices in the digital fine arts while refining conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms as powerful tools for generating and communicating images and ideas.\"}],\"text\":\"ART 428 explores digital fine arts practices, teaching students to generate and communicate ideas through static and moving imagery.\"},\"topics\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"current and historical practices in the digital fine arts\"}],\"text\":\"Current and historical digital fine arts practices\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing/post-production, and narrative or non-narrative 2D animation\"}],\"text\":\"Digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing, and 2D animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"fine art context\"}],\"text\":\"Fine art context for digital media\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260906T231458-5fdd2fff","observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-5291a20b802b9bbbe22b24cb","output_id":"f0e2a24505372855a8075b002e9de4a6d91a05c234a634da469bb9bc4de601f5","section":"student_experience","status":"insufficient_evidence","value_json":"{\"status\":\"insufficient_evidence\",\"themes\":[]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-5590a4969e0a630fe46a86e8","output_id":"e73b71ad382c8ca9635671942006df61cf1d83dd225311bc928536aa7cb5c714","section":"requirements","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"nodes\":[{\"children\":[\"n1\",\"n2\",\"n3\",\"n4\",\"n5\",\"n6\"],\"condition\":null,\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"(ART 107,176,318,429, or529) or declared in an Art graduate program\",\"id\":\"n0\",\"kind\":\"any\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":107,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"ART 107\",\"id\":\"n1\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":176,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"176\",\"id\":\"n2\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":318,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"318\",\"id\":\"n3\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":429,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"429\",\"id\":\"n4\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":529,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"529\",\"id\":\"n5\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":\"declared in an Art graduate program\",\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"declared in an Art graduate program\",\"id\":\"n6\",\"kind\":\"condition\"}],\"notes\":[],\"root\":\"n0\",\"status\":\"parsed\"}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-5590a4969e0a630fe46a86e8","output_id":"e73b71ad382c8ca9635671942006df61cf1d83dd225311bc928536aa7cb5c714","section":"search_profile","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"assumed_background\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 107\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"An introduction to a range of digital media techniques for artists and designers, including digital imaging, vector graphics, web design and 3D digital modeling.\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 429\",\"field\":\"requirements_text\",\"quote\":\"ART 107or declared in an Art graduate program\"}],\"text\":\"Foundational digital media techniques and imaging tools\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 318\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"An introduction to time-based art forms including video, installation, and visual art performance.\"}],\"text\":\"Time-based art forms such as video and performance\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 429\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Introduction to three-dimensional modeling in the computer, in particular the use of 3D digital models for the creation of images and objects.\"}],\"text\":\"3D digital modeling concepts\"}],\"search_phrases\":[\"digital fine arts studio\",\"digital imaging graduate course\",\"ART 428 digital art\",\"digital painting video editing animation\"],\"skills_taught\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Students will create and manipulate both static and moving imagery\"}],\"text\":\"Creation and manipulation of static and moving imagery\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"implications for digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing/post-production, and narrative or non-narrative 2D animation\"}],\"text\":\"Digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing, and 2D animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"refining conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms as powerful tools for generating and communicating images and ideas\"}],\"text\":\"Conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms\"}],\"summary\":{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Explore current and historical practices in the digital fine arts while refining conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms as powerful tools for generating and communicating images and ideas.\"}],\"text\":\"ART 428 explores digital fine arts practices, teaching students to generate and communicate ideas through static and moving imagery.\"},\"topics\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"current and historical practices in the digital fine arts\"}],\"text\":\"Current and historical digital fine arts practices\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing/post-production, and narrative or non-narrative 2D animation\"}],\"text\":\"Digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing, and 2D animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"fine art context\"}],\"text\":\"Fine art context for digital media\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-5590a4969e0a630fe46a86e8","output_id":"e73b71ad382c8ca9635671942006df61cf1d83dd225311bc928536aa7cb5c714","section":"student_experience","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"status\":\"supported\",\"themes\":[{\"aspect\":\"workload\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"},{\"comment\":\"Stephen was always around to provide feedback. Don't get me wrong- if you don't put work into this course you won't pass. Need to understand the software he teaches you and it's not something you can just wait until the night before and wing it. As long as you give ample time towards your projects, start early and ask for feedback you'll have fun.\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":5,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":2,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2021\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"mixed\",\"summary\":\"Students report a significant time commitment, with one noting 6 hours of weekly homework and another emphasizing that the course requires ample time for projects and cannot be rushed.\"},{\"aspect\":\"teaching_clarity\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"},{\"comment\":\"Stephen was always around to provide feedback. Don't get me wrong- if you don't put work into this course you won't pass. Need to understand the software he teaches you and it's not something you can just wait until the night before and wing it. As long as you give ample time towards your projects, start early and ask for feedback you'll have fun.\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":5,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":2,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2021\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"mixed\",\"summary\":\"Feedback on the instructor is polarized; one student found the professor unfriendly with excessively long lectures, while another appreciated his constant availability for feedback.\"},{\"aspect\":\"assessment\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":1,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2016\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"negative\",\"summary\":\"The course involves intense critiques and complex video tutorials, which some students found stressful and boring.\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20261014T203208-0851c9a1","observed_at":"2026-10-14 17:50:09.728220+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"e722b813d06209290bcbe42f718f76544e37be4807dcd7f2ab9c3738c2fca867","record_version_id":"ff88ca7c91785e77f66b43ee1f2de9e4c6c948473f7b6a1cceab986e9e4e9e56","job_id":"enrich-6556a505c10f448d98d02466","output_id":"4640df1146fbe96ede7abc747793f0118025ed3e1e23aae15f14a5cf4a5f16fe","section":"requirements","status":"needs_review","value_json":"{\"nodes\":[{\"children\":[\"r1_any\",\"r2_cond\"],\"condition\":null,\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"(ART 107,176,318,429, or529) or (declared in an Art MFA or Design + Innovation MS)\",\"id\":\"root\",\"kind\":\"any\"},{\"children\":[\"c_art107\",\"c_art176\",\"c_art318\",\"c_art429\",\"c_art529\"],\"condition\":null,\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"(ART 107,176,318,429, or529)\",\"id\":\"r1_any\",\"kind\":\"any\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":107,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"ART 107\",\"id\":\"c_art107\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":176,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"176\",\"id\":\"c_art176\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":318,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"318\",\"id\":\"c_art318\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":429,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"429\",\"id\":\"c_art429\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":529,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"or529\",\"id\":\"c_art529\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":\"declared in an Art MFA or Design + Innovation MS\",\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"declared in an Art MFA or Design + Innovation MS\",\"id\":\"r2_cond\",\"kind\":\"condition\"}],\"notes\":[],\"root\":\"root\",\"status\":\"parsed\"}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B","model_revision":"1d4bf0f2ff6012fd82039f2fa52739d0dd7c60c0","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20261014T203208-0851c9a1","observed_at":"2026-10-14 17:50:09.728220+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"e722b813d06209290bcbe42f718f76544e37be4807dcd7f2ab9c3738c2fca867","record_version_id":"ff88ca7c91785e77f66b43ee1f2de9e4c6c948473f7b6a1cceab986e9e4e9e56","job_id":"enrich-6556a505c10f448d98d02466","output_id":"4640df1146fbe96ede7abc747793f0118025ed3e1e23aae15f14a5cf4a5f16fe","section":"search_profile","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"activity_tags\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Learn a range of 2D animation techniques and how to create and manipulate images and video using software tools to create narrative or fine art videos.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"label\":\"programming\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":1,\"quote\":\"Demonstrate pre-production techniques including mind mapping, story boarding, screenplays, and animatics.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"label\":\"writing\"}],\"assumed_background\":[],\"search_phrases\":[\"2D digital animation studio\",\"narrative or fine art video production\",\"animation principles and pre-production\",\"rotoscoped hand animation techniques\",\"digital imaging for artists\",\"storyboarding and animatics in animation\"],\"skills_taught\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":0,\"quote\":\"Understand the 12 principles of animation.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Understanding the 12 principles of animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":1,\"quote\":\"Demonstrate pre-production techniques including mind mapping, story boarding, screenplays, and animatics.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Applying pre-production techniques like mind mapping, storyboarding, and animatics\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":3,\"quote\":\"Understand the techniques involved in the following animation types, 2D digital limited animation, 2D digital full animation, 2.5D digital full animation, and rotoscoped hand animation.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Executing various 2D and 2.5D digital animation styles including rotoscopy\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":6,\"quote\":\"Incorporate digital imaging techniques into research.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Integrating digital imaging methods into artistic research\"}],\"summary\":{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"title\",\"quote\":\"2D ANIMATION STUDIO\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Focused on 2D digital animation. Learn a range of 2D animation techniques and how to create and manipulate images and video using software tools to create narrative or fine art videos.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"A studio course focused on 2D digital animation, teaching students to use software tools to create narrative or fine art videos while exploring the history and current practice of the field.\"},\"topics\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Explore history and current practice in this emerging field of fine art and the implications of these tools for artists\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"History and contemporary practice of digital animation as fine art\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":4,\"quote\":\"Understand the elements and principles of design in the context of the moving image.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Design elements and principles applied to moving images\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"official_learning_outcomes\",\"outcome_index\":5,\"quote\":\"understand contemporary practice in the field, including the use of image manipulation in fine art, design and entertainment.\",\"source_url\":\"https://guide.wisc.edu/courses/art/\"}],\"text\":\"Image manipulation across fine art, design, and entertainment sectors\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B","model_revision":"1d4bf0f2ff6012fd82039f2fa52739d0dd7c60c0","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20261014T203208-0851c9a1","observed_at":"2026-10-14 17:50:09.728220+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"e722b813d06209290bcbe42f718f76544e37be4807dcd7f2ab9c3738c2fca867","record_version_id":"ff88ca7c91785e77f66b43ee1f2de9e4c6c948473f7b6a1cceab986e9e4e9e56","job_id":"enrich-6556a505c10f448d98d02466","output_id":"4640df1146fbe96ede7abc747793f0118025ed3e1e23aae15f14a5cf4a5f16fe","section":"student_experience","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"status\":\"supported\",\"themes\":[{\"aspect\":\"workload\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"},{\"comment\":\"Stephen was always around to provide feedback. Don't get me wrong- if you don't put work into this course you won't pass. Need to understand the software he teaches you and it's not something you can just wait until the night before and wing it. As long as you give ample time towards your projects, start early and ask for feedback you'll have fun.\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":5,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":2,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2021\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"negative\",\"subject_instructor_id\":null,\"summary\":\"Students report a high workload involving extensive homework and complex tutorials, with one reviewer noting that success requires ample time and early starts rather than last-minute effort.\"},{\"aspect\":\"teaching_clarity\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stephen was always around to provide feedback. Don't get me wrong- if you don't put work into this course you won't pass. Need to understand the software he teaches you and it's not something you can just wait until the night before and wing it. As long as you give ample time towards your projects, start early and ask for feedback you'll have fun.\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":5,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":1,\"review_ids\":[\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2021\",\"review_year_start\":\"2021\"},\"sentiment\":\"positive\",\"subject_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"summary\":\"Cited reviews praise Stephen Hilyard for being available to provide feedback, though they emphasize that students must actively understand the taught software.\"},{\"aspect\":\"organization\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":1,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2016\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"negative\",\"subject_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"summary\":\"One reviewer criticized Stephen Hilyard's lectures as excessively long and suggested that class time could have been better utilized for in-class work.\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"Qwen/Qwen3.8-27B","model_revision":"1d4bf0f2ff6012fd82039f2fa52739d0dd7c60c0","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260906T231458-5fdd2fff","observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-789789da373eecc1ff75f626","output_id":"bd706d66722504cb34fbf4b575a711b40581429a7721c53e80f82b85e82e18c6","section":"requirements","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"nodes\":[{\"children\":[\"n1\",\"n2\",\"n3\",\"n4\",\"n5\",\"n6\"],\"condition\":null,\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"(ART 107,176,318,429, or529) or declared in an Art graduate program\",\"id\":\"n0\",\"kind\":\"any\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":107,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"ART 107\",\"id\":\"n1\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":176,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"176\",\"id\":\"n2\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":318,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"318\",\"id\":\"n3\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":429,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"429\",\"id\":\"n4\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":529,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"529\",\"id\":\"n5\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":\"declared in an Art graduate program\",\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"declared in an Art graduate program\",\"id\":\"n6\",\"kind\":\"condition\"}],\"notes\":[],\"root\":\"n0\",\"status\":\"parsed\"}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260906T231458-5fdd2fff","observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-789789da373eecc1ff75f626","output_id":"bd706d66722504cb34fbf4b575a711b40581429a7721c53e80f82b85e82e18c6","section":"search_profile","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"assumed_background\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 107\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"An introduction to a range of digital media techniques for artists and designers, including digital imaging, vector graphics, web design and 3D digital modeling.\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 429\",\"field\":\"requirements_text\",\"quote\":\"ART 107or declared in an Art graduate program\"}],\"text\":\"Foundational digital media techniques and imaging tools\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 318\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"An introduction to time-based art forms including video, installation, and visual art performance.\"}],\"text\":\"Time-based art forms such as video and performance\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 429\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Introduction to three-dimensional modeling in the computer, in particular the use of 3D digital models for the creation of images and objects.\"}],\"text\":\"3D digital modeling concepts\"}],\"search_phrases\":[\"digital fine arts studio\",\"digital imaging graduate course\",\"ART 428 digital art\",\"digital painting video editing animation\"],\"skills_taught\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Students will create and manipulate both static and moving imagery\"}],\"text\":\"Creation and manipulation of static and moving imagery\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"implications for digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing/post-production, and narrative or non-narrative 2D animation\"}],\"text\":\"Digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing, and 2D animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"refining conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms as powerful tools for generating and communicating images and ideas\"}],\"text\":\"Conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms\"}],\"summary\":{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Explore current and historical practices in the digital fine arts while refining conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms as powerful tools for generating and communicating images and ideas.\"}],\"text\":\"ART 428 explores digital fine arts practices, teaching students to generate and communicate ideas through static and moving imagery.\"},\"topics\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"current and historical practices in the digital fine arts\"}],\"text\":\"Current and historical digital fine arts practices\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing/post-production, and narrative or non-narrative 2D animation\"}],\"text\":\"Digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing, and 2D animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"fine art context\"}],\"text\":\"Fine art context for digital media\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260906T231458-5fdd2fff","observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-789789da373eecc1ff75f626","output_id":"bd706d66722504cb34fbf4b575a711b40581429a7721c53e80f82b85e82e18c6","section":"student_experience","status":"insufficient_evidence","value_json":"{\"status\":\"insufficient_evidence\",\"themes\":[]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-8b774950c2b6adfdc46d1b82","output_id":"d6aa45a8c7ac787118d641dd8c011b9e716087f25f4ab258b81f570868935cb8","section":"requirements","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"nodes\":[{\"children\":[\"n1\",\"n2\",\"n3\",\"n4\",\"n5\",\"n6\"],\"condition\":null,\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"(ART 107,176,318,429, or529) or declared in an Art graduate program\",\"id\":\"n0\",\"kind\":\"any\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":107,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"ART 107\",\"id\":\"n1\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":176,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"176\",\"id\":\"n2\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":318,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"318\",\"id\":\"n3\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":429,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"429\",\"id\":\"n4\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":null,\"course\":{\"course_number\":529,\"minimum_grade\":null,\"subjects\":[\"ART\"],\"timing\":\"prior\"},\"evidence\":\"529\",\"id\":\"n5\",\"kind\":\"course\"},{\"children\":[],\"condition\":\"declared in an Art graduate program\",\"course\":null,\"evidence\":\"declared in an Art graduate program\",\"id\":\"n6\",\"kind\":\"condition\"}],\"notes\":[],\"root\":\"n0\",\"status\":\"parsed\"}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-8b774950c2b6adfdc46d1b82","output_id":"d6aa45a8c7ac787118d641dd8c011b9e716087f25f4ab258b81f570868935cb8","section":"search_profile","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"assumed_background\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 107\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"An introduction to a range of digital media techniques for artists and designers, including digital imaging, vector graphics, web design and 3D digital modeling.\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 429\",\"field\":\"requirements_text\",\"quote\":\"ART 107or declared in an Art graduate program\"}],\"text\":\"Foundational digital media techniques and imaging tools\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 318\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"An introduction to time-based art forms including video, installation, and visual art performance.\"}],\"text\":\"Time-based art forms such as video and performance\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 429\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Introduction to three-dimensional modeling in the computer, in particular the use of 3D digital models for the creation of images and objects.\"}],\"text\":\"3D digital modeling concepts\"}],\"search_phrases\":[\"digital fine arts studio\",\"digital imaging graduate course\",\"ART 428 digital art\",\"digital painting video editing animation\"],\"skills_taught\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Students will create and manipulate both static and moving imagery\"}],\"text\":\"Creation and manipulation of static and moving imagery\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"implications for digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing/post-production, and narrative or non-narrative 2D animation\"}],\"text\":\"Digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing, and 2D animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"refining conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms as powerful tools for generating and communicating images and ideas\"}],\"text\":\"Conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms\"}],\"summary\":{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"Explore current and historical practices in the digital fine arts while refining conceptual and technical understanding of digital art forms as powerful tools for generating and communicating images and ideas.\"}],\"text\":\"ART 428 explores digital fine arts practices, teaching students to generate and communicate ideas through static and moving imagery.\"},\"topics\":[{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"current and historical practices in the digital fine arts\"}],\"text\":\"Current and historical digital fine arts practices\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing/post-production, and narrative or non-narrative 2D animation\"}],\"text\":\"Digital drawing, painting, print-making, video editing, and 2D animation\"},{\"evidence\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"field\":\"description\",\"quote\":\"fine art context\"}],\"text\":\"Fine art context for digital media\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-8b774950c2b6adfdc46d1b82","output_id":"d6aa45a8c7ac787118d641dd8c011b9e716087f25f4ab258b81f570868935cb8","section":"student_experience","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"status\":\"supported\",\"themes\":[{\"aspect\":\"workload\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"},{\"comment\":\"Stephen was always around to provide feedback. Don't get me wrong- if you don't put work into this course you won't pass. Need to understand the software he teaches you and it's not something you can just wait until the night before and wing it. As long as you give ample time towards your projects, start early and ask for feedback you'll have fun.\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":5,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":2,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2021\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"mixed\",\"summary\":\"Students report a significant time commitment, with one noting 6 hours of weekly homework and another emphasizing that the course requires ample time for projects and cannot be rushed.\"},{\"aspect\":\"teaching_clarity\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"},{\"comment\":\"Stephen was always around to provide feedback. Don't get me wrong- if you don't put work into this course you won't pass. Need to understand the software he teaches you and it's not something you can just wait until the night before and wing it. As long as you give ample time towards your projects, start early and ask for feedback you'll have fun.\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":5,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":2,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2021\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"mixed\",\"summary\":\"Feedback on the instructor is polarized; one student found the professor unfriendly with excessively long lectures, while another appreciated his constant availability for feedback.\"},{\"aspect\":\"assessment\",\"evidence\":[{\"comment\":\"Stressful due to the large amount of homework (6 hours a week of boring and complex video tutorials), intense critiques, and overall not friendly professor. Lectures were excessively long and time could have been better used for in-class work time. Also - why is it required to buy an expensive drawing tablet if we never used it?\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"difficulty_rating\":4,\"id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"quality_rating\":2,\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\"}],\"evidence_count\":1,\"review_ids\":[\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\"],\"scope\":{\"historical\":true,\"instructors\":[{\"id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\"}],\"review_year_end\":\"2016\",\"review_year_start\":\"2016\"},\"sentiment\":\"negative\",\"summary\":\"The course involves intense critiques and complex video tutorials, which some students found stressful and boring.\"}]}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_uid":"course_fa2e784493e9fee631cac7dd","course_id":"ART 428","catalog_version_id":"dd862ce8b86889d52d878ebda2c7ac698ba070aeb9bdd648092fd341e655a387","record_version_id":"5b143f2e7f83d4f49d231e4ee28f5d8103e5338fa726c04f2c8c3c2e7ff4a0d6","job_id":"enrich-8b774950c2b6adfdc46d1b82","output_id":"d6aa45a8c7ac787118d641dd8c011b9e716087f25f4ab258b81f570868935cb8","section":"student_summary","status":"valid","value_json":"{\"context_hash\":\"37ac944ca016d4b2af72e18130149b8412459fb788b13d2b4409776fe6d26d91\",\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"current_instructors\":[{\"instructor_uid\":\"instructor_ddfe311de4bbb39dfe4461b7\",\"message\":\"No course-specific reviews available\",\"name\":\"Robyn Das-Romain\",\"review_status\":\"no_course_reviews\",\"rmp_instructor_id\":null,\"summary\":[]}],\"difficulty_workload\":[{\"citations\":[{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"},{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"}],\"text\":\"Historical reviews of Stephen Hilyard: Reviewers report high workload involving six hours of weekly video tutorials and complex projects, noting that success requires starting early and understanding the taught software rather than cramming.\"}],\"errors\":[],\"historical_context\":[{\"citations\":[{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"},{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"}],\"text\":\"No reviews exist for current instructor Robyn Das-Romain. Historical reviews for Stephen Hilyard describe a course with intense critiques and high workload. Students note he provides feedback but requires significant time investment and early project starts to succeed.\"}],\"message\":null,\"offered\":true,\"profile_hash\":\"5cb4dabf887cdbcd8c00d5a1312e10828b95c63f30bc3ea76aea199565390d02\",\"quick_take\":[{\"citations\":[{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"},{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"}],\"text\":\"Historical reviews for Stephen Hilyard describe a demanding course requiring significant time investment and software proficiency, with mixed experiences regarding the professor's demeanor and feedback availability.\"},{\"citations\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1254\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1262\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1264\",\"type\":\"grade\"}],\"text\":\"Recent recorded grades — Spring 2025: 3.82 GPA, 95.5% A/AB (n=22 letter grades); Fall 2025: 3.86 GPA, 96.0% A/AB (n=25 letter grades); Spring 2026: 4.00 GPA, 100.0% A/AB (n=24 letter grades).\"}],\"student_experience\":[{\"citations\":[{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2016-12-03 22:49:05 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"30bf4547c6070406ccc530bf\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTI3MzIzMjgw\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"},{\"instructor_name\":\"Stephen Hilyard\",\"review_date\":\"2021-12-14 17:57:29 +0000 UTC\",\"review_id\":\"31efd7cfa4c11ac66384b186\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"source_instructor_id\":\"rmp:1429932\",\"source_review_id\":\"UmF0aW5nLTM1NTE5MDAy\",\"source_url\":\"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1429932\",\"type\":\"review\"}],\"text\":\"Historical reviews of Stephen Hilyard: Experiences vary: one reviewer found the professor unfriendly with excessive lectures, while another appreciated Hilyard's availability for feedback and found the course fun with ample effort.\"}],\"task_hash\":\"74fb0997943e888960bbc9e47db8c4fd12e4292d55c20509d8d89db6a9910f68\",\"teaching_history\":[{\"citations\":[{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1164\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1172\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1174\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1182\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1184\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1222\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1232\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1234\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1242\",\"type\":\"grade\"},{\"course_id\":\"ART 428\",\"run_id\":\"20260907T155543-ce3781c4\",\"section_number\":1,\"source_course_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"source_record\":{\"entity_id\":\"25a62954-6025-3fe3-a125-a63b4d7b0acc\",\"file\":\"tables/observations.parquet\",\"kind\":\"grades\",\"source\":\"madgrades\"},\"table\":\"section_grades_latest\",\"term_id\":\"1252\",\"type\":\"grade\"}],\"text\":\"STEPHEN HILYARD is recorded teaching in Spring 2016, Fall 2016, Spring 2017, Fall 2017, Spring 2018, Fall 2021, Fall 2022, Spring 2023, Fall 2023, Fall 2024. Recorded history may be incomplete and does not establish a future schedule.\"}],\"term_id\":\"1272\",\"term_name\":\"2026 Fall\",\"version\":2}","candidate_json":null,"error":null,"model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","selected_for_release":false}]