{"schema_version":1,"url":"https://uwcourses.com/courses/PHILOS_951","title":"PHILOS 951: Seminar-philosophy of Mind | UW–Madison","dataset":{"revision":"e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349","repository":"twangodev/uwcourses","schema_version":6,"importer_version":"7","projection_id":"52a78527ff09011d88cb04c7d43867d9fbfec2930bf1dd2ec359ebd2844e0b07","observed_at":"2026-09-07T15:55:43.033547+00:00","built_at":"2026-09-10T19:50:42.743001+00:00","courses":8951,"current_instructors":5754,"limited":false,"terms":["1272","1264","1262","1254","1252","1244","1242","1234","1232","1224","1222","1212","1204","1202","1194","1192","1184","1182","1174","1172","1164","1162","1154","1152","1144","1142","1134","1132","1124","1122","1114","1112","1104","1102","1094","1092","1084","1082","1074","1072"],"term":"1272","departments":[{"subject":"AAE","count":90},{"subject":"ABT","count":20},{"subject":"ACCTIS","count":36},{"subject":"ACTSCI","count":14},{"subject":"AFAERO","count":10},{"subject":"AFRICAN","count":87},{"subject":"AFROAMER","count":71},{"subject":"AGROECOL","count":21},{"subject":"AMERIND","count":53},{"subject":"ANAT&PHY","count":7},{"subject":"ANATOMY","count":2},{"subject":"ANESTHES","count":8},{"subject":"ANSCI","count":57},{"subject":"ANTHRO","count":95},{"subject":"ART","count":125},{"subject":"ARTED","count":10},{"subject":"ARTHIST","count":121},{"subject":"ASIALANG","count":129},{"subject":"ASIAN","count":109},{"subject":"ASIANAM","count":28},{"subject":"ASTRON","count":38},{"subject":"ATMOCN","count":69},{"subject":"BIOCHEM","count":51},{"subject":"BIOCORE","count":10},{"subject":"BIOLOGY","count":14},{"subject":"BIOMDSCI","count":18},{"subject":"BME","count":66},{"subject":"BMI","count":41},{"subject":"BMOLCHEM","count":10},{"subject":"BOTANY","count":69},{"subject":"BSE","count":44},{"subject":"C&ESOC","count":73},{"subject":"CBE","count":48},{"subject":"CHEM","count":101},{"subject":"CHICLA","count":52},{"subject":"CIVENGR","count":133},{"subject":"CLASSICS","count":47},{"subject":"CNP","count":10},{"subject":"CNSRSCI","count":50},{"subject":"COMARTS","count":137},{"subject":"COMPBIO","count":15},{"subject":"COMPLIT","count":11},{"subject":"COMPSCI","count":138},{"subject":"COUNPSY","count":78},{"subject":"CRB","count":19},{"subject":"CS&D","count":71},{"subject":"CSCS","count":40},{"subject":"CURRIC","count":193},{"subject":"DANCE","count":93},{"subject":"DERM","count":8},{"subject":"DS","count":88},{"subject":"DYSCI","count":35},{"subject":"ECE","count":155},{"subject":"ECON","count":145},{"subject":"EDPOL","count":114},{"subject":"EDPSYCH","count":97},{"subject":"ELPA","count":70},{"subject":"EMA","count":53},{"subject":"EMERMED","count":17},{"subject":"ENGL","count":206},{"subject":"ENTOM","count":40},{"subject":"ENVIRST","count":148},{"subject":"EP","count":15},{"subject":"EPD","count":67},{"subject":"ESL","count":16},{"subject":"F&WECOL","count":60},{"subject":"FAMMED","count":22},{"subject":"FINANCE","count":50},{"subject":"FOLKLORE","count":40},{"subject":"FOODSCI","count":43},{"subject":"FRENCH","count":63},{"subject":"GEN&WS","count":145},{"subject":"GENBUS","count":72},{"subject":"GENECSLR","count":17},{"subject":"GENETICS","count":60},{"subject":"GEOG","count":113},{"subject":"GEOSCI","count":83},{"subject":"GERMAN","count":82},{"subject":"GLE","count":48},{"subject":"GNS","count":38},{"subject":"GREEK","count":27},{"subject":"HDFS","count":41},{"subject":"HEBR-BIB","count":13},{"subject":"HEBR-MOD","count":10},{"subject":"HISTORY","count":233},{"subject":"HISTSCI","count":56},{"subject":"HONCOL","count":13},{"subject":"ILS","count":43},{"subject":"INFOSYS","count":9},{"subject":"INTEGART","count":7},{"subject":"INTEGSCI","count":22},{"subject":"INTER-AG","count":18},{"subject":"INTER-HE","count":11},{"subject":"INTER-LS","count":22},{"subject":"INTEREGR","count":16},{"subject":"INTLBUS","count":21},{"subject":"INTLST","count":50},{"subject":"ISYE","count":83},{"subject":"ITALIAN","count":53},{"subject":"JEWISH","count":56},{"subject":"JOURN","count":88},{"subject":"KINES","count":128},{"subject":"LACIS","count":26},{"subject":"LANDARC","count":61},{"subject":"LATIN","count":24},{"subject":"LAW","count":120},{"subject":"LEGALST","count":48},{"subject":"LINGUIS","count":35},{"subject":"LIS","count":89},{"subject":"LITTRANS","count":78},{"subject":"LSC","count":52},{"subject":"M&ENVTOX","count":7},{"subject":"MARKETNG","count":62},{"subject":"MATH","count":153},{"subject":"MDGENET","count":8},{"subject":"ME","count":130},{"subject":"MEDHIST","count":43},{"subject":"MEDICINE","count":60},{"subject":"MEDIEVAL","count":32},{"subject":"MEDPHYS","count":39},{"subject":"MEDSC-M","count":29},{"subject":"MEDSC-V","count":41},{"subject":"MHR","count":68},{"subject":"MICROBIO","count":45},{"subject":"MILSCI","count":16},{"subject":"MM&I","count":22},{"subject":"MOLBIOL","count":6},{"subject":"MS&E","count":59},{"subject":"MUSIC","count":165},{"subject":"MUSPERF","count":126},{"subject":"NAVSCI","count":20},{"subject":"NE","count":44},{"subject":"NEURODPT","count":11},{"subject":"NEUROL","count":7},{"subject":"NEURSURG","count":4},{"subject":"NTP","count":11},{"subject":"NURSING","count":111},{"subject":"NUTRSCI","count":65},{"subject":"OBS&GYN","count":18},{"subject":"OCCTHER","count":39},{"subject":"ONCOLOGY","count":14},{"subject":"OPHTHALM","count":5},{"subject":"OTM","count":43},{"subject":"PATH","count":34},{"subject":"PATH-BIO","count":29},{"subject":"PEDIAT","count":26},{"subject":"PHARMACY","count":31},{"subject":"PHILOS","count":77},{"subject":"PHMCOL-M","count":11},{"subject":"PHMPRAC","count":45},{"subject":"PHMSCI","count":60},{"subject":"PHYASST","count":37},{"subject":"PHYSICS","count":88},{"subject":"PHYSIOL","count":3},{"subject":"PHYTHER","count":37},{"subject":"PLANTSCI","count":52},{"subject":"PLPATH","count":35},{"subject":"POLISCI","count":192},{"subject":"POPHLTH","count":58},{"subject":"PORTUG","count":33},{"subject":"PSYCH","count":101},{"subject":"PSYCHIAT","count":22},{"subject":"PUBAFFR","count":54},{"subject":"PUBLHLTH","count":23},{"subject":"RADIOL","count":11},{"subject":"REALEST","count":41},{"subject":"RELIGST","count":90},{"subject":"RHABMED","count":9},{"subject":"RMI","count":24},{"subject":"RP&SE","count":102},{"subject":"S&APHM","count":17},{"subject":"SCANDST","count":73},{"subject":"SLAVIC","count":89},{"subject":"SOC","count":149},{"subject":"SOCWORK","count":87},{"subject":"SOILSCI","count":46},{"subject":"SPANISH","count":83},{"subject":"SRMED","count":21},{"subject":"STAT","count":94},{"subject":"STDYABRD","count":52},{"subject":"STS","count":8},{"subject":"SURGERY","count":25},{"subject":"SURGSCI","count":33},{"subject":"THEATRE","count":91},{"subject":"URBRPL","count":60},{"subject":"UROLOGY","count":5},{"subject":"ZOOLOGY","count":89}],"deployed_at":null},"data":{"course":{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","record_version_id":"101a6f63b0057c33fd7dde59f61efc4f4f3fc79acdb5970e1f93790e286ab246","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","catalog_version_id":"6d90c9b7aa900ecf6bc213a00743dc7865e1d2615c9fd7e804eafc6efed02e7b","course_number":951,"subjects":["PHILOS"],"title":"SEMINAR-PHILOSOPHY OF MIND","description":"Seminar on philosophy of mind.","requirements_text":"Declared in Philosophy graduate program","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"credit_offering_ids":["1272:736:014787","1272:736:014787.29"],"llm_job_id":"enrich-8b774950c2b6adfdc46d1b82","llm_output_id":"88db2709470c5b5858a69c976817eef74034dfd9d1bc01860c33a3330f5dc09d","llm_model":"nvidia/Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-NVFP4","llm_model_revision":"1355db6a052410cfd62085d94b58866fd0f2c3c5","llm_task_version":"14","llm_search_status":"valid","llm_summary":"A graduate seminar focused on the philosophy of mind.","llm_topics":["Philosophy of mind"],"llm_skills":[],"llm_assumed_background":[],"llm_search_phrases":["philosophy of mind seminar","PHILOS 951 graduate","philosophy of mind topics"],"llm_requirements_status":"needs_review","llm_student_summary_status":"valid","llm_experience_status":"insufficient_evidence","catalog_variants":[],"student_summary":{"context_hash":"f42d414576f1ca1d8326b9f22b515b59948e01baa814afa41abdc6780d528d56","course_id":"PHILOS 951","current_instructors":[{"instructor_uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","message":"No course-specific reviews available","name":"Farid Masrour","review_status":"no_course_reviews","rmp_instructor_id":"rmp:1932844","summary":[{"citations":[{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","section_number":1,"source_course_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"section_grades_latest","term_id":"1194","type":"grade"},{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","section_number":1,"source_course_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"section_grades_latest","term_id":"1224","type":"grade"},{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","section_number":1,"source_course_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"section_grades_latest","term_id":"1242","type":"grade"}],"text":"Recent recorded grades — Spring 2019: 4.00 GPA, 100.0% A/AB (n=8 letter grades); Spring 2022: 3.82 GPA, 81.8% A/AB (n=11 letter grades); Fall 2023: 3.90 GPA, 100.0% A/AB (n=5 letter grades). Includes jointly taught sections."}]}],"difficulty_workload":[],"errors":[],"historical_context":[],"message":"No course-specific reviews available","offered":true,"profile_hash":"5cb4dabf887cdbcd8c00d5a1312e10828b95c63f30bc3ea76aea199565390d02","quick_take":[{"citations":[{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"grades_latest","term_id":"1222","type":"grade"},{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"grades_latest","term_id":"1224","type":"grade"},{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"grades_latest","term_id":"1242","type":"grade"}],"text":"Recent recorded grades — Fall 2021: 3.88 GPA, 92.3% A/AB (n=13 letter grades); Spring 2022: 3.82 GPA, 81.8% A/AB (n=11 letter grades); Fall 2023: 3.90 GPA, 100.0% A/AB (n=5 letter grades)."}],"student_experience":[],"task_hash":"74fb0997943e888960bbc9e47db8c4fd12e4292d55c20509d8d89db6a9910f68","teaching_history":[{"citations":[{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","section_number":1,"source_course_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"section_grades_latest","term_id":"1154","type":"grade"},{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","section_number":1,"source_course_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"section_grades_latest","term_id":"1174","type":"grade"},{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","section_number":1,"source_course_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"section_grades_latest","term_id":"1194","type":"grade"},{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","section_number":1,"source_course_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"section_grades_latest","term_id":"1224","type":"grade"},{"course_id":"PHILOS 951","run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","section_number":1,"source_course_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","source_record":{"entity_id":"1261187c-fe51-3991-8867-ec11b6f01290","file":"tables/observations.parquet","kind":"grades","source":"madgrades"},"table":"section_grades_latest","term_id":"1242","type":"grade"}],"text":"FARID MASROUR is recorded teaching in Spring 2015, Spring 2017, Spring 2019, Spring 2022, Fall 2023. Recorded history may be incomplete and does not establish a future schedule."}],"term_id":"1272","term_name":"2026 Fall","version":2},"requirements":{"nodes":[{"children":[],"condition":"Declared in Philosophy graduate program","course":null,"evidence":"Declared in Philosophy graduate program","id":"n0","kind":"condition"}],"notes":["Unlinked course mention 'Philosophy graduate program' requires review for canonical identity."],"root":"n0","status":"needs_review"},"instructors":[{"instructor_uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","source":"enrollment","source_instructor_id":"masrour","identity_basis":"netid","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"Farid Masrour","email":"MASROUR@WISC.EDU","first_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","ratings":{"review_count":26,"quality":3.38,"difficulty":2.81,"quality_count":26,"difficulty_count":26,"profile_id":"rmp:1932844","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1932844","match_basis":"exact_name","observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:39:21.546761+00:00","courses":{"course_4da92585f9a43ecce6347d2b":{"review_count":1,"quality":5,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1},"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7":{"review_count":1,"quality":3,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1},"course_c1aeabd1a79ddbbc49e0e21e":{"review_count":7,"quality":3.14,"difficulty":2.71,"quality_count":7,"difficulty_count":7}},"bayesian_quality":3.501602514585476,"prior_mean":3.6596857835465957,"prior_weight":20},"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"}],"offerings":[{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","offering_id":"1272:736:014787","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1272","source_course_id":"014787","source_subject_id":"736","title":"Seminar-Philosophy of Mind","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"typically_offered":"Occasionally"},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","offering_id":"1272:736:014787.29","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1272","source_course_id":"014787.29","source_subject_id":"736","title":"Perception and Cognition","credits_min":3,"credits_max":3,"typically_offered":"Occasionally"}],"sections":[{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","section_uid":"uw-section:1272:35730","term_id":"1272","source_section_id":"35730","identity_basis":"class_number","section_number":"001","section_type":"SEM","instruction_mode":"Classroom Instruction","capacity":20,"enrolled":12,"waitlisted":0,"start_date":"2026-09-02 05:00:00+00:00","end_date":"2026-12-09 06:00:00+00:00"}],"grade_instructors":[{"instructor_uid":"instructor_95ca993ee5fb40bc53aa2b76","source":"madgrades","source_instructor_id":"4109634","identity_basis":"source_id","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"ERIC A MARGOLIS","email":null,"first_observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","grade_statistics":{"gpa":3.197,"graded":363,"counts":[55,110,155,25,13,2,3],"sections":8},"instructor_url":"/instructors/ERIC_A_MARGOLIS"},{"instructor_uid":"instructor_ad1a39c925607862310218e0","source":"madgrades","source_instructor_id":"1040405","identity_basis":"source_id","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"MARTHA GIBSON","email":null,"first_observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","ratings":{"review_count":74,"quality":3.77,"difficulty":3.09,"quality_count":74,"difficulty_count":74,"profile_id":"rmp:18444","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/18444","match_basis":"exact_name","observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:20:22.154889+00:00","courses":{"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7":{"review_count":12,"quality":3.92,"difficulty":3.08,"quality_count":12,"difficulty_count":12},"course_902ab056721ed2c6be9738ad":{"review_count":1,"quality":5,"difficulty":4,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1}},"bayesian_quality":3.746528890116297,"prior_mean":3.6596857835465957,"prior_weight":20},"grade_statistics":{"gpa":3.287,"graded":2504,"counts":[806,662,590,231,157,27,31],"sections":76},"instructor_url":"/instructors/MARTHA_GIBSON--instructor_ad1a39c925607862310218e0"},{"instructor_uid":"instructor_c9eadc7a69df9d4e1081a7d5","source":"madgrades","source_instructor_id":"2600422","identity_basis":"source_id","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"LARRY SHAPIRO","email":null,"first_observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","ratings":{"review_count":81,"quality":4.64,"difficulty":2.35,"quality_count":81,"difficulty_count":81,"profile_id":"rmp:269987","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/269987","match_basis":"exact_name","observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:24:18.870870+00:00","courses":{"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7":{"review_count":8,"quality":4.5,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":8,"difficulty_count":8}},"bayesian_quality":4.445878372979523,"prior_mean":3.6596857835465957,"prior_weight":20},"grade_statistics":{"gpa":3.27,"graded":2707,"counts":[787,831,610,247,149,50,33],"sections":107},"instructor_url":"/instructors/LARRY_SHAPIRO--instructor_c9eadc7a69df9d4e1081a7d5"},{"instructor_uid":"instructor_9bb0d4277375364f5ff234dc","source":"madgrades","source_instructor_id":"4753015","identity_basis":"source_id","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"SARAH PAUL","email":null,"first_observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","ratings":{"review_count":33,"quality":3.67,"difficulty":2.85,"quality_count":33,"difficulty_count":33,"profile_id":"rmp:1501901","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1501901","match_basis":"exact_name","observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:07:02.300563+00:00","courses":{"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7":{"review_count":3,"quality":3.33,"difficulty":3,"quality_count":3,"difficulty_count":3},"course_a1a2dbd6666b2eb51d01a6c2":{"review_count":1,"quality":4,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1},"course_4da92585f9a43ecce6347d2b":{"review_count":1,"quality":2,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1}},"bayesian_quality":3.6661078428477722,"prior_mean":3.6596857835465957,"prior_weight":20},"grade_statistics":{"gpa":3.234,"graded":1058,"counts":[242,328,311,110,43,12,12],"sections":32},"instructor_url":"/instructors/SARAH_PAUL--instructor_9bb0d4277375364f5ff234dc"},{"instructor_uid":"instructor_fdc4825bdb240a3d0cc74280","source":"madgrades","source_instructor_id":"5407974","identity_basis":"source_id","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"FARID MASROUR","email":null,"first_observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","ratings":{"review_count":26,"quality":3.38,"difficulty":2.81,"quality_count":26,"difficulty_count":26,"profile_id":"rmp:1932844","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1932844","match_basis":"exact_name","observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:39:21.546761+00:00","courses":{"course_4da92585f9a43ecce6347d2b":{"review_count":1,"quality":5,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1},"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7":{"review_count":1,"quality":3,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1},"course_c1aeabd1a79ddbbc49e0e21e":{"review_count":7,"quality":3.14,"difficulty":2.71,"quality_count":7,"difficulty_count":7}},"bayesian_quality":3.501602514585476,"prior_mean":3.6596857835465957,"prior_weight":20},"grade_statistics":{"gpa":3.328,"graded":1373,"counts":[596,285,213,129,94,38,18],"sections":60},"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR--instructor_fdc4825bdb240a3d0cc74280"},{"instructor_uid":"instructor_375a57407f014d779c46dec5","source":"madgrades","source_instructor_id":"3758161","identity_basis":"source_id","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"HAYLEY CLATTERBUCK","email":null,"first_observed_at":"2026-09-06 23:14:58.172943+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","ratings":{"review_count":3,"quality":5,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":3,"difficulty_count":3,"profile_id":"rmp:2769725","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/2769725","match_basis":"exact_name","observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:37:03.663792+00:00","courses":{"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7":{"review_count":1,"quality":5,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1}},"bayesian_quality":3.8345093769970395,"prior_mean":3.6596857835465957,"prior_weight":20},"grade_statistics":{"gpa":3.76,"graded":404,"counts":[264,97,36,3,4,0,0],"sections":22},"instructor_url":"/instructors/HAYLEY_CLATTERBUCK"},{"instructor_uid":"instructor_896da6e58a92d24711a6a370","source":"enrollment","source_instructor_id":"masrour","identity_basis":"netid","identity_status":"source_identified","name":"Farid Masrour","email":"MASROUR@WISC.EDU","first_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","last_observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","ratings":{"review_count":26,"quality":3.38,"difficulty":2.81,"quality_count":26,"difficulty_count":26,"profile_id":"rmp:1932844","source_url":"https://www.ratemyprofessors.com/professor/1932844","match_basis":"exact_name","observed_at":"2026-09-07 16:39:21.546761+00:00","courses":{"course_4da92585f9a43ecce6347d2b":{"review_count":1,"quality":5,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1},"course_432c74beba85cb7bdc1287f7":{"review_count":1,"quality":3,"difficulty":2,"quality_count":1,"difficulty_count":1},"course_c1aeabd1a79ddbbc49e0e21e":{"review_count":7,"quality":3.14,"difficulty":2.71,"quality_count":7,"difficulty_count":7}},"bayesian_quality":3.501602514585476,"prior_mean":3.6596857835465957,"prior_weight":20},"instructor_url":"/instructors/FARID_MASROUR"}],"grades":[{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1074","term_name":"Spring 2007","instructors":["ERIC A MARGOLIS"],"a":11,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":11,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1082","term_name":"Fall 2007","instructors":["Martha Gibson"],"a":11,"ab":1,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":1,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":13,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1092","term_name":"Fall 2008","instructors":["Larry Shapiro"],"a":8,"ab":3,"b":1,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":1,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":13,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1094","term_name":"Spring 2009","instructors":["Martha Gibson"],"a":7,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":7,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1102","term_name":"Fall 2009","instructors":["Larry Shapiro"],"a":7,"ab":5,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":12,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1112","term_name":"Fall 2010","instructors":["Larry Shapiro"],"a":4,"ab":1,"b":1,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":6,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":12,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1132","term_name":"Fall 2012","instructors":["Larry Shapiro"],"a":8,"ab":4,"b":2,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":14,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1142","term_name":"Fall 2013","instructors":["SARAH PAUL"],"a":2,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":11,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":13,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1152","term_name":"Fall 2014","instructors":["Martha Gibson"],"a":8,"ab":1,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":9,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1154","term_name":"Spring 2015","instructors":["Farid Masrour"],"a":7,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":1,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":8,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1172","term_name":"Fall 2016","instructors":["Martha Gibson"],"a":9,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":9,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1174","term_name":"Spring 2017","instructors":["Farid Masrour"],"a":0,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":0,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1182","term_name":"Fall 2017","instructors":["Larry Shapiro"],"a":4,"ab":1,"b":1,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":1,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":7,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1194","term_name":"Spring 2019","instructors":["Farid Masrour"],"a":8,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":1,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":1,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":10,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1202","term_name":"Fall 2019","instructors":["Larry Shapiro"],"a":6,"ab":0,"b":3,"bc":0,"c":1,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":2,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":12,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1222","term_name":"Fall 2021","instructors":["HAYLEY CLATTERBUCK","Larry Shapiro"],"a":11,"ab":1,"b":1,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":6,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":19,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1224","term_name":"Spring 2022","instructors":["Farid Masrour"],"a":9,"ab":0,"b":2,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":11,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1234","term_name":"Spring 2023","instructors":["Martha Gibson"],"a":0,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":0,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1242","term_name":"Fall 2023","instructors":["Farid Masrour","Larry Shapiro"],"a":4,"ab":1,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":1,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":6,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]},{"run_id":"20260907T155543-ce3781c4","semester":"1272","observed_at":"2026-09-07 15:55:43.033547+00:00","course_id":"PHILOS 951","course_uid":"course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e","term_id":"1254","term_name":"Spring 2025","instructors":["Larry Shapiro"],"a":0,"ab":0,"b":0,"bc":0,"c":0,"d":0,"f":0,"satisfactory":0,"unsatisfactory":0,"credit":0,"no_credit":0,"passed":0,"incomplete":0,"no_work":0,"not_reported":0,"other":0,"total":0,"source_aliases":["PHILOS 951"]}],"statistics":{"gpa":3.857,"graded":154,"counts":[124,18,11,0,1,0,0]},"grade_conflicts":[],"evidence":{"history":["/data/e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349/history/course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e-0.json"],"traces":["/data/e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349/traces/course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e-0.json"],"meetings":["/data/e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349/meetings/course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e-0.json"],"results":["/data/e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349/results/course_17a1e616c8eabaf76539a85e-0.json"]},"revision":"e243353dcb7d79b7247ced91d69443ef4c2a6349"},"context":null,"instructorTrends":[{"uid":"instructor_c9eadc7a69df9d4e1081a7d5","name":"LARRY SHAPIRO","count":71,"terms":[{"term":"1092","count":12,"sections":1,"gpa":3.7916666666666665},{"term":"1102","count":12,"sections":1,"gpa":3.7916666666666665},{"term":"1112","count":6,"sections":1,"gpa":3.75},{"term":"1132","count":14,"sections":1,"gpa":3.7142857142857144},{"term":"1182","count":6,"sections":1,"gpa":3.75},{"term":"1202","count":10,"sections":1,"gpa":3.5},{"term":"1222","count":6,"sections":1,"gpa":3.8333333333333335},{"term":"1242","count":5,"sections":1,"gpa":3.9}]},{"uid":"instructor_ad1a39c925607862310218e0","name":"MARTHA GIBSON","count":37,"terms":[{"term":"1082","count":12,"sections":1,"gpa":3.9583333333333335},{"term":"1094","count":7,"sections":1,"gpa":4},{"term":"1152","count":9,"sections":1,"gpa":3.9444444444444446},{"term":"1172","count":9,"sections":1,"gpa":4}]},{"uid":"instructor_fdc4825bdb240a3d0cc74280","name":"FARID MASROUR","count":31,"terms":[{"term":"1154","count":7,"sections":1,"gpa":4},{"term":"1194","count":8,"sections":1,"gpa":4},{"term":"1224","count":11,"sections":1,"gpa":3.8181818181818183},{"term":"1242","count":5,"sections":1,"gpa":3.9}]},{"uid":"instructor_95ca993ee5fb40bc53aa2b76","name":"ERIC A MARGOLIS","count":11,"terms":[{"term":"1074","count":11,"sections":1,"gpa":4}]},{"uid":"instructor_375a57407f014d779c46dec5","name":"HAYLEY CLATTERBUCK","count":7,"terms":[{"term":"1222","count":7,"sections":1,"gpa":3.9285714285714284}]},{"uid":"instructor_9bb0d4277375364f5ff234dc","name":"SARAH PAUL","count":2,"terms":[{"term":"1142","count":2,"sections":1,"gpa":4}]}],"following":[],"projection":null}}